Do lens hoods need to match a lens’s focal length and angle of view?

Asked 7/9/2015

5 views

2 answers

0

If two lenses have the same filter-thread diameter, can they use the same screw-in or generic hood? I’ve read that focal length matters, but many hoods sold online only list thread size. How do focal length, sensor size, and lens type affect whether a hood will work without causing vignetting?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

5

Most lenses from the major manufacturers have a proprietary connector that the hood uses to attach to the front of the lens. While you can purchase hoods that attach to filter threads, that doesn't guarantee the hood will work properly with a lens it can screw onto. This is because:

I read that the focal length plays a role...

It's even more involved than that: focal length plus sensor size play a role since ultimately it is about the angle of view. This distinction is most often applied to telephoto lenses, which yield a fairly narrow angle of view. There are a few cases of lenses that have two different hoods available: one for the wider angle of view yielded with a larger (typically FF sensor) and another for the narrower angle of view yielded with a smaller (typically APS-C) sensor.

If you want to have some fun with this concept, try printing and constructing a paper/cardboard lens hood for your lens from lenshood.net which will be for use on APS-C cameras and another hood for the same lens from lenshood.co.uk that will be the correct size for that lens when mounted on a Full Frame camera. Then compare the two hoods. If you use the hood designed for the crop body on the FF camera, you will see vignetting as a result of the hood blocking some of the light that would wind up in the part of the image circle cast by the lens that falls on a FF sensor but that does not fall on an APS-C sensor.

If you want to go the economical route, you're probably better off buying a third party hood made to fit to a particular lens, such as this one for under $10 meant to replace the OEM ET-87 from Canon that runs about $60. There are also a variety of other third party ET-87 copies available at various prices and quality levels. Other hoods for other lenses have a similar variety of options out there as well.

It's also not just focal length that pays a role in hood design. If the front of the lens rotates during focusing or zooming, a circular hood should be used that is as short as the shortest corner of a tulip-shaped hood for a lens with the same angle of view and front element size and position.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. Matching filter-thread size alone does not guarantee a hood will work.

A hood must be sized for the lens’s angle of view, which depends mainly on focal length and also on sensor size/crop factor. Wide-angle lenses need shorter hoods so the hood doesn’t appear in the frame. Longer lenses can use deeper hoods because their angle of view is narrower.

If you put a hood designed for a longer lens on a wider lens, you can get visible corner darkening or even see the hood itself in the image. This can be more obvious when stopped down. Zooms are a compromise: one hood must work across the lens’s whole zoom range, especially the widest setting.

Fit also matters. Many manufacturer hoods use proprietary bayonet mounts, not just filter threads, so a hood that screws on may physically fit but still be the wrong shape or depth.

Universal rubber or screw-in hoods can work, but they still need to be chosen for the lens’s field of view, not just thread diameter.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer