Can two polarizers be used as a variable ND filter, and what are the drawbacks vs a true ND filter?

Asked 6/2/2011

6 views

2 answers

0

Can you stack two polarizing filters and rotate them to vary light transmission like a variable ND filter? If so, how does that compare with using a dedicated neutral density filter? I'm interested in practical drawbacks such as color cast, reflections, vignetting, flare, uneven darkening on wide lenses, autofocus compatibility, and the amount of light reduction possible.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

25

  • Polarizers are often more expensive than ND filters and you need two of them.

  • Stacking two filters can cause vignetting with wide lenses.

  • You have an extra glass surface with two polarizers which can cause flare and potentially loss of contrast/sharpness.

  • This arrangement can cause colour shift toward yellow (but so some ND filters).

  • Extreme wide angle lenses will exhibit uneven darkening due to the difference in incidence angle across the polarizers.

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. Two polarizers can act as a variable ND: rotate them relative to each other and transmission changes from roughly one polarizer’s normal loss (about 1.5–2 stops) to very dark. In practice, this is essentially how variable ND filters work.

Drawbacks versus a true ND filter:

  • Polarizer effects remain. They reduce reflections and can darken skies, which an ND filter does not do.
  • Color shifts can appear, especially near maximum attenuation (for example yellow or purple casts).
  • More glass/air surfaces can increase flare and reduce contrast.
  • Stacking filters can cause vignetting, especially on wide lenses.
  • Very wide-angle lenses can show uneven darkening because light hits the filters at different angles.
  • Two polarizers may cost more than a single ND filter.

Compatibility note: the light must remain polarized between the two filters. A front linear polarizer works, or a circular polarizer mounted reversed; if you need autofocus, the rear filter should be a circular polarizer.

So: yes, it works, but a dedicated ND is usually preferable when you want neutral, even light reduction without the side effects of polarization.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer