Can two polarizing filters be used as a variable ND filter?
Asked 9/22/2010
3 views
1 answers
0
I’ve read that stacking two polarizing filters can act like a variable neutral density filter. Is that actually possible, and how is it set up? What are the drawbacks, such as color casts, uneven darkening, or image quality issues? Roughly how much light reduction can you expect from this method?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
1 Answer
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes. Two polarizing elements can act as a variable light reducer: rotate one relative to the other and the transmission changes from fairly bright to much darker. In practice, variable ND filters are based on this idea.
Setup is simple in principle: stack two polarizing filters and rotate one. However, there are tradeoffs:
- It is not perfectly neutral, so color casts can appear.
- Image quality can drop because you’re adding more glass.
- At stronger settings, uneven darkening or other artifacts may appear, especially with wide lenses.
- Metering/autofocus can become less reliable as the view gets very dark.
Light reduction is variable rather than fixed. The exact range depends on the filters used and their orientation, but it can span from modest reduction to several stops. It will not usually reach perfect blackout, and the darkest setting may also be the least clean optically.
So: yes, it works, but it’s a compromise. It can be useful for experimentation, but a purpose-made variable ND is usually more predictable and convenient.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can two polarizers be used as a variable ND filter, and what are the drawbacks vs a true ND filter?
Are variable ND filters as good as fixed ND filters?
Why aren’t variable ND filters made from two polarizers more popular?
Do variable ND filters give the same results as fixed ND filters?
Why does my variable ND filter create dark spots at 18mm?