How does a variable ND filter work compared with stacking two polarizers?
Asked 10/28/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I understand what ND filters and polarizers do, and that rotating two polarizers can reduce light transmission. In theory, how does a variable ND filter work, and what is the practical/theoretical difference between a dedicated variable ND and simply stacking two polarizers and rotating them?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
2
Matt Grum is right but I can think of one difference.
Variable Polarizers have a well known problem with very wide angle lens. You get strange banding in your image since the light travels so obliquely through the filters.
Two polarizers could have a greater gap between them which could exacerbate this effect.
Originally by user7310. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user7310
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A variable ND filter works on the same basic principle as two polarizing elements rotated relative to each other: as their alignment changes, they pass less light.
So in theory, a variable ND is essentially a controlled pair of polarizers built into one filter. The practical differences are mostly in implementation and side effects rather than a different optical principle.
One issue noted with variable polarizers is with very wide-angle lenses: you can get uneven darkening or banding because light hits the filter at very oblique angles across the frame. If you stack two separate polarizers, the greater spacing between them can make this effect worse.
So the key difference is not that a variable ND uses a fundamentally different theory, but that a dedicated variable ND packages the polarizing elements more tightly and predictably. That can help reduce some problems, though wide-angle banding can still occur.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Are variable ND filters as good as fixed ND filters?
Why aren’t variable ND filters made from two polarizers more popular?
Can two polarizers be used as a variable ND filter, and what are the drawbacks vs a true ND filter?
How does a variable ND filter work, and does it also act like a polarizer?
Should I choose a linear or circular polarizer for DSLR use and for a DIY variable ND setup?