Can the NEC PA271W be hardware-calibrated with a third-party colorimeter like the Spyder3 Elite?
Asked 11/2/2012
4 views
2 answers
0
I'm considering the NEC PA271W for its wide-gamut panel, brightness uniformity, and hardware LUT calibration. I already own a Datacolor Spyder3 Elite and want to know whether it can be used with NEC SpectraView/SpectraView II for true hardware calibration, or whether the PA271W requires a different supported sensor. If the Spyder3 isn't suitable, which types of calibrators are known to work better with this display?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
3
First, yours won't work well. From the NEC FAQ:
Why are the Spyder color sensors not recommended for use with wide color gamut displays such as the LCD2690WUXi, LCD2690WUXi2, LCD3090WQXi, P221W, PA241W, PA271W and PA301W models?
Our evaluation of these devices has determined that the accuracy of measurements when used with wide color gamut displays could lead to large color errors. Therefore we do not recommend using this device on wide color gamut displays.
Other than that, support depends on the operating system:
For Linux its:
- X -Rite/GretagMacbeth Eye-One Display V2.
- X-Rite iOne Display Pro
- NEC MDSVSENSOR
- NEC SpectraSensor Pro
For Windows its:
- NEC MDSVSENSOR
- NEC SpectraSensor Pro
- X-Rite/GretagMacbeth iOne Pro and iOne Monitor
- X-Rite iOne Pro2
- X-Rite/GretagMacbeth iOne Display V1 and V2
- X-Rite DTP94 / MonacoOPTIX-XR
- X-Rite ColorMunki
- X-Rite iOne Display Pro
- ColorVision/Datacolor Spyder2
- Datacolor Spyder3
- Datacolor Spyder4
- BasICColor Discus
For Mac:
- NEC MDSVSENSOR
- NEC SpectraSensor Pro
- X-Rite/GretagMacbeth iOne Pro and iOne Monitor
- X-Rite iOne Pro2
- X-Rite/GretagMacbeth iOne Display V1 and V2
- X-Rite DTP94 / MonacoOPTIX-XR
- X-Rite ColorMunki
- X-Rite iOne Display Pro
- ColorVision/Datacolor Spyder2
- Datacolor Spyder3
- Datacolor Spyder4
- BasICColor Discus
So, yours is supported but should not be used on a wide-gamut display. I use NEC's software and device and it works very well. I save money by only buying it once to calibrate all 3 NEC displays here, so it comes to $100 per monitor :)
Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1620
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Probably not with the Spyder3 Elite. NEC specifically does not recommend Spyder sensors for its wide-gamut displays, including the PA271W, because their measurements can produce large color errors. So even if detection is possible in some software versions, the results may be inconsistent or inaccurate.
For hardware LUT calibration on the PA271W, SpectraView support depends on software/OS version, but the commonly supported and better-performing options mentioned are NEC-branded SpectraView sensors and X-Rite devices. Community experience in the answers says the X-Rite i1 Display Pro gave the most consistent, low-delta results, while ColorMunki Photo was usable but sometimes less consistent.
So the practical takeaway is:
- Don’t rely on a Spyder3 for a wide-gamut NEC PA271W.
- Use NEC SpectraView-compatible hardware.
- If buying a sensor, an X-Rite i1 Display Pro is the safest choice from the devices discussed.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do Lightroom and Photoshop need a monitor ICC profile for accurate color on a hardware-calibrated display?
Can I use free Windows software with an NEC MDSVSENSOR3 colorimeter?
Why does my monitor calibration disappear briefly after standby and then return?
Why does my NEC wide-gamut monitor measure smaller than sRGB after calibration?
Why do Spyder4Elite and DisplayCAL behave differently when calibrating a monitor?