Do Lightroom and Photoshop need a monitor ICC profile for accurate color on a hardware-calibrated display?
Asked 1/20/2018
7 views
2 answers
0
I replaced an NEC LCD2490WUXi2 with an ASUS PA329Q and calibrated both to the same target: sRGB, D65, 150 nits, gamma 2.2. The NEC was calibrated with SpectraView and the ASUS with ProArt Calibration. Lightroom shows very different color on the two displays, and the ASUS software does not seem to create or update a monitor ICC profile like SpectraView or i1Profiler does. If a display is hardware-calibrated using its internal LUT, do Lightroom and Photoshop still need an accurate monitor ICC profile to render color correctly? Could a mode mismatch such as sRGB vs Adobe RGB also cause the large difference?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
1
The color output must be normalized to be true.
This can happen in two different ways:
- On the computer through the software.
- On the screen by the hardware.
Higher-end screens often have a LUT (Look-up Table) that can be changed. This will do the color correction in the screen itself.
The monitor details say that it is"factory pre-calibrated for outstanding color accuracy" and the specification states that it has the ability to use a 14-bit LUT.
Lightroom can send uncorrected Adobe RGB and the monitor corrects it. Additionally, Lightroom and the monitor must both be using the same mode (Adobe RGB, SRGB etc.) or the wrong LUT will be applied.
Originally by user41735. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user41735
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—color has to be normalized somehow, either in software on the computer or in the monitor’s own hardware LUT. A display like the ASUS ProArt can apply correction internally, which is one reason higher-end monitors support hardware calibration and 14-bit LUTs.
But color-managed apps still need the display path to be consistent. If Lightroom/Photoshop and the monitor are not using the same mode/profile assumption—such as sRGB vs Adobe RGB—the wrong correction can be applied and colors can look very wrong.
So a hardware-calibrated monitor can handle much of the correction itself, but accurate display rendering still depends on the monitor being in the intended color mode and the system/app using matching color management expectations. A mode mismatch is a likely cause of the large difference you’re seeing.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do I need a different ICC profile when switching a wide-gamut monitor into sRGB emulation mode?
How can I make Lightroom under Wine use my monitor ICC profile?
In Photoshop, should I use “Proof Colors > Monitor RGB” to see accurate color on a calibrated monitor?
Why do colors look different across apps after monitor calibration?
Do I need a monitor with an sRGB mode for accurate photo and video work?