Are third-party or refilled ink cartridges worth using for photo printing?

Asked 2/17/2011

2 views

2 answers

0

Original-brand ink is expensive, and many companies sell cheaper compatible cartridges or refill services. For home printing, are third-party or refilled inks a good value? I'm especially interested in whether they hold up for printing photos, including color accuracy, longevity, printer reliability, and whether existing paper/printer profiles still work.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

12

In theory, one could make great third-party inks, but in practicality, I don't think any of them trade on permanence or color quality. They trade on cheapness.

I have a friend who ran out of brand-name ink in a pinch on a project and ended up printing some of it with refills; at first, one had to know in order to tell which was which, but after a week, anyone could see.

I've seen several articles on this over the years — here's one originally from pcworld, 2003. That's a long time ago in technology-time, but I don't think the landscape has really changed on this point.

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For photo printing, usually no. The main benefit of third-party or refilled cartridges is lower cost, but the tradeoff is often color accuracy, consistency, and print longevity. Printer/paper ICC profiles are typically made for the manufacturer’s original inks, so changing inks can make profiles inaccurate and shift color output. Some users report acceptable results for general-purpose printing, design proofs, or noncritical work, and cheap compatibles can seem fine at first. But for photographs and quality prints on profiled paper, community experience says they’re generally not worth it. There are also potential concerns about clogging, recognition issues, and long-term stability. If you print very high volumes, a consistent third-party ink plus custom profiling could work, but that adds complexity and cost. In short: good for office graphics or draft prints, but stick with OEM ink for dependable photo quality.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer