Are there affordable 77mm 12–15 stop screw-in ND filters besides Singh-Ray?

Asked 2/1/2015

3 views

2 answers

0

I'm looking for a low-profile 77mm screw-in neutral density filter in the 12–15 stop range for long exposures. Singh-Ray's 15-stop option seems very expensive, and I want to avoid stacking filters because I shoot very wide and get severe vignetting. I'm also not interested in a square filter holder system. Are there any more reasonably priced alternatives, and are there any budget options worth considering?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

10

It's easy to lost perspective when referring to stops due to the fact that it is a logarithmic scale. When talking about ND filters each stop represents a halving of the intensity of incoming light. Like grains of rice on a chessboard it starts to add up very quickly.

A 15 stop ND filter reduces incoming light intensity by a factor of 32,768. That's enough to turn what would be a hand-holdable 1/50s exposure into well over ten minutes. This makes it a pretty specialist piece of equipment.

Given the specialist nature of a 15 stop filter (which is therefore manufactured in small quantities, unable to benefit from economies of scale), along with difficulties in actually producing such a dense filter that doesn't result in a strong colour cast it is unsurprising to find one with a $450 pricetag.

If you really need to be able to do ten minute exposures in broad daylight, then a more economical solution would be to pick up a 10-stop ND filter shoot 30 exposures of 20 second each with an intervalometer, and then stack them in software. As a bonus you'll also get a boost in dynamic range!

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. Very dense ND filters in the 12–15 stop range are a niche product, so higher prices are normal: a 15-stop filter cuts light by 32,768×, and making one with minimal color cast is difficult.

From the answers, a practical alternative is the Formatt Hitech 16-stop 77mm screw-in ND, reported at around 150 euros with no noticeable color cast. That fits your preference for a simple screw-in filter and should be far less expensive than the Singh-Ray option.

For an ultra-budget experiment, some photographers try welding glass. It can work for very long exposures, but it’s more of a DIY compromise than a proper photographic ND filter and may be less convenient or neutral in color.

So if you want a usable photographic solution without stacking or a square system, a 77mm Formatt Hitech 16-stop screw-in filter is the strongest recommendation from the community answers.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer