Are some tripod heads more secure than others, and does price matter?
Asked 11/10/2013
2 views
2 answers
0
My Nikon D5100 with a 55-300mm lens slipped off my tripod while shooting stars. I had checked that it seemed mounted correctly, stepped away, and the camera fell. Fortunately the damage was minor.
I’m trying to understand what likely caused this and whether I should replace the tripod/head. Specifically:
- Is this more likely to be incorrect mounting, a quick-release/head problem, or an overloaded tripod/head?
- Are some tripod head and mounting systems more secure than others for beginners?
- Does paying more for a tripod/head usually buy better safety, or mostly lighter materials and convenience?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
5
Most tripod heads have ratings for how much weight they are able to support. If you place 10 pounds of camera/lens on a head designed for four pounds, it doesn't matter how well made it is, it will eventually fail. The same is true of the tripod 'legs' themselves. They all have a maximum weight rating.
From your question it is unclear if your camera fell off the tripod head or if the entire tripod fell over with your camera still attached. In either case, I would be reluctant to trust a D5100 and a 55-300 lens on the tripod you linked to. It just looks a little too flimsy for my taste. I own a different Ravelli tripod that I use often, but it is a much heavier duty model and I have a heavier duty head on top of it.
Even when you have a set of legs and a head that are rated to handle the weight of your camera and lens, you still need to be sure everything is in proper adjustment. Depending on the design, the locks on each leg section need to be tightened periodically if they are the lever type locks. The amount of tension on the head needs to be adjusted for the amount the camera and lens weigh as well as the angle at which you want them to be held. Various quick release systems need to be either tightened or locked in, again depending on the specific design. A single loose adjustment anywhere could be enough to cause a failure that could result in damage to your camera. Designs that provide a form of positive feedback, such as the Manfrotto RC2 or RC4 quick release systems that click into place, might be better for a novice. But even the Manfrotto design can be 'clicked' into place without the other side of the camera plate wedged securely under the edge of the receiving plate. I've caught my camera + 70-200 f/2.8 headed to the ground with my left hand on a couple of such occasions.
Regardless of what design you use, it is never a bad practice to "test" things a little after mounting a camera and lens on a tripod or other support. Grip the camera and gently try to rock it back and forth or pull it away. You will discover quickly when you have failed to secure everything correctly.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, some tripod/head systems are more secure than others, but the biggest factors are proper mounting and using gear within its load rating.
A camera can fall either because the quick-release plate/head wasn’t fully engaged, the clamp loosened, or the head/tripod was overloaded. Load rating matters for both the legs and the head. A long lens also increases leverage when tilted, so the effective stress can be higher than the camera’s simple weight suggests.
In general, a direct 1/4" screw connection is very secure but slower. Quick-release systems are more convenient, but they must be locked correctly. Some users prefer friction-clamp styles; others prefer auto-locking quick-release systems because they reduce the chance of incomplete attachment.
Price can matter if it buys:
- higher load capacity
- a stronger, better-made head
- better locking mechanisms
- lighter materials such as carbon fiber
For safety, choose a tripod and head with a comfortable margin above your camera/lens weight, make sure the plate is tightened to the camera, and confirm the quick-release is fully locked before letting go.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does a tripod ball head get stiff in cold weather, and can you prevent it?
How do I choose a ball head for a Manfrotto 190XPROB and Panasonic G3?
What screw is on top of my tripod, and how do I make it usable with a DSLR?
How do I mount a Nikon D90 on a tripod head with an alignment pin?
Does studio strobe flash tube size affect power, heat, or lifespan?