Will my RGB photos look worse when a book printer converts them to CMYK?
Asked 8/3/2017
6 views
2 answers
0
I created a photo book from RAW-converted JPEGs and liked the results from Costco’s online book printing. Now I have the book laid out as a PDF in InDesign for another printer that uses offset printing and CMYK. Since my images are currently RGB, I’m worried the printed nature photos may look dull after conversion. At this stage, is there anything practical I can do to help make sure the book still prints well?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
4
If you were greatly satisfied by the results from Costco, then you will likely be happy with the results from PrintNinja. Both parties have to do color conversions to CMYK and similarly rooted ink systems for images received in RGB (any other color space as well). The difference here is that Costco didn't tell you they were going to do it implicitly.
PrintNinja's website states two options for color conversion from RGB to CMYK, one implicit and one explicit.
Method 1: Let Us Convert Your Colors For You (Less Control)
The simplest method is just to submit your RGB files and let us convert them for you. We’ll show you the CMYK files in your Electronic Proof before going to press, so you’ll be able to see exactly how your colors have changed in the conversion process.
However, this method provides the least amount of control for you, since we won’t make any changes to your colors beyond the conversion. If you want to be able to tweak your colors after conversion, you should convert them on your end before uploading your artwork.
Method 2: Convert Colors Yourself (More Control)
If you want the most possible control over your colors, we recommend you convert colors on your end.
If you do nothing further, they will proceed with Method 1, and you can expect the results I've mentioned above.
If it's not too late to resubmit your book, you can do the following to extract the most fidelity from your printing process, and use PrintNinja's second option:
- If possible, export your images again from your workflow as 16-bit TIFFs using the "Japan Color 2001 Coated" ICC profile (as mentioned on PrintNinja's page). The ICC profile can be obtained from Adobe here.
- Have your designer replace the old images in the InDesign file.
- If you have any colored graphics, such as horizontal rules, icons, or vector art in your book, have your designer check for color values that are not specified in CMYK, and select replacement values in CMYK. PrintNinja recommends a number of specific CMYK values for best results.
- Also, verify with your designer that the text (presumably in black) in your book is specified using only a K-value (100 or 100% => C=0,M=0,Y=0,K=100), and not the synthetic value (C=100,M=100,Y=100,K=0-100) or any such analogue. Rich Black and similarly constructed color values can cause issues with ink bleed in print.
- Last, your designer can export a new pdf file that you can submit to PrintNinja.
One last note, if you wanted to do the same with Costco, they recommend following the preparation guide here for in-store printing; and using profiles from here for send-out printing.
Originally by user19985. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user19985
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Probably not a major problem. Any company printing your photos on paper must ultimately print in CMYK or a similar ink-based process, even if you upload RGB files. Costco was also converting your images for print—you just didn’t have to think about it.
The main difference is control. Your new printer may either convert the RGB files for you or let you handle the conversion yourself. If they provide an electronic proof after conversion, review that carefully, since it will show how colors changed before printing.
RGB can display some colors on a screen that CMYK can’t reproduce exactly, so some very vivid colors may lose a little saturation. But that does not mean the whole book will look bad or dull. Good printing workflows are designed for this.
Practical advice: use the printer’s recommended workflow, check any proofs they provide, and make adjustments only if something specific looks off. If you were happy with Costco’s printed results, there’s a good chance you’ll also be happy with another competent printer.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which photo book services offer true photo-quality printing, PDF/InDesign upload, and short runs?
For an InDesign photo book, should I place high-resolution JPEGs or TIFFs for best print quality?
Why do photo labs accept RGB files while print shops often require CMYK?
How can I export a PDF for printing without losing photo sharpness?
What offline software can I use to design professional photo books for export to a printer?