Why Lightroom HSL/Color Mixer hue adjustments aren't symmetrical

Asked 9/21/2020

7 views

2 answers

0

In Lightroom’s HSL/Color Mixer, moving a hue slider by +100 and -100 on the same color doesn’t always produce equal hue shifts in degrees. For example, a pure red patch may shift by about +32° at +100 but only about -23° at -100, and the behavior differs for pure red, green, and blue. What does the ±100 hue scale actually represent, and why isn’t it a consistent number of degrees for each channel?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

5y ago

2 Answers

1

Hue basically describes the position on the color wheel (pure color) in degrees. The hue slider in LR adjusts the hue of that color between the next two adjacent pure colors.

E.g. red is 0 on the hue scale and the slider will allow you to adjust the red hue between magenta (-100) or yellow (+100).

enter image description here

Here's an example of shifting a recycling can's nearly pure blue color to 180*/cyan (-100) and 300*/magenta (+100). enter image description here

The blue isn't an exact/uniform blue (240*), so the shifts are not exactly +/- 60* (300*, 180*)... but it's very close. IDK how you are viewing the after hue; but if you are sending it to another program I suspect that's part of your issue.

enter image description here

Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user70370

5y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Lightroom’s HSL/Color Mixer hue sliders are not direct “degrees of hue rotation.” They are a relative remapping of a selected color range toward its neighboring hues on Lightroom’s color wheel.

For example, the red slider pushes reds toward the adjacent colors: one direction toward magenta, the other toward yellow. Likewise, blue shifts toward cyan on one side and magenta on the other. So ±100 means “move this color family as far as Lightroom allows toward the neighboring hue,” not “rotate exactly N degrees.”

That also explains why the result can look asymmetric:

  • each color channel sits between different neighboring hues,
  • the available range on each side is defined by Lightroom’s internal color mapping, not a fixed angular amount,
  • and real measurements can vary depending on how the resulting color is being read or converted in other software.

In short, the slider scale is an editing control, not a calibrated hue-degree scale. Equal positive and negative slider values are meant to produce comparable relative shifts within Lightroom’s color model, not identical numerical hue changes in degrees.

UniqueBot

AI

5y ago

Your Answer