How does Lightroom’s Saturation adjustment affect hue and lightness?
Asked 3/31/2015
3 views
2 answers
0
I compared the same pixel before and after increasing Saturation in Lightroom and found that the result did not look like a simple increase of the S value in HSL/HSV. For example:
Before: RGB 159,189,233 HSL 216°, 32%, 91%
After: RGB 99,183,255 HSL 208°, 61%, 100%
The hue and lightness/value also changed, not just saturation. Why does this happen? Does Lightroom use a different working color space or a different algorithm rather than directly changing HSL saturation?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
1
I am not sure. I don't currently have lightroom at my disposal, but I think it has to do with the colour profile conversions, and color spaces.
If an image is reduced to another color space it has less information, so the colors "wraps" to the lower color space model.
Here is for example a conversion (in PS) from pure rgb model to a cmyk simulation, and the cian and magenta shifted a little in a hue wheel.
Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user37321
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Lightroom is not simply taking your pixel, converting it to HSL, increasing S, and converting it back unchanged in every other respect. Its adjustments are done in a wide-gamut internal workflow (commonly described as ProPhoto RGB–based), and profile conversions or export color-space changes can also shift measured values.
Based on the shared tests, a pure Lightroom Saturation increase caused only a very small hue change when kept in the same color space. Larger shifts appeared when color profiles changed, such as working in a wider space and then exporting to sRGB.
So the most likely explanation is:
- Lightroom’s saturation control is not a simple HSL/HSV S-only edit.
- The image may be processed in a different working space than the one used to inspect values.
- Converting between profiles/spaces can change RGB numbers and slightly alter derived HSL/HSV hue/lightness readings.
In short: yes, Lightroom uses its own internal processing pipeline, and the hue/lightness changes you measured are likely due mostly to that processing plus color-profile conversion, not a straightforward HSL saturation operation.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do GIMP's Hue/Saturation/Color/Value blend modes work the same way as Photoshop's color blend modes?
What is the Darktable equivalent of Lightroom’s HSL panel?
Why can cyan look brighter than red on an RGB monitor?
How do different black-and-white conversion methods affect the final image?
How does Lightroom’s HSL panel divide and blend color ranges?



