Why is autofocus less reliable in Live View than through the optical viewfinder on a Canon 650D?

Asked 7/22/2014

2 views

2 answers

0

I use a Canon EOS 650D with the EF-S 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6 IS STM. In low light, autofocus in Live View is noticeably harder to achieve, and sometimes it will not lock focus at all even when I tap the screen to choose the AF point. Why does autofocus behave differently in Live View compared with using the optical viewfinder? What causes the difference, and are there any ways to improve Live View focusing when I need to hold the camera above my head?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

6

This is the difference between CDAF (contrast detection) with integrated PDAF hybrid pixels vs full PDAF(phase detection). When using live view, the camera's imaging sensor is exposed and it tries to focus by using a combination of hunting for focus and checking the image contrast mixed with some hybrid pixels that contain limited phase detect focus capability. Generally speaking, CDAF should work better in low light, but it also takes longer and doesn't work well if contrast is low.

When in optical view finder mode on the other hand, the full PDAF sensor is exposed to the image and can be used to quickly get pretty accurate readings. It still requires vertical or horizontal lines, but doesn't require the same hunting for focus.

It is a little bit weird that you couldn't get focus at all with live view but could under the same conditions with the view finder, but it is expected that it would be a bit slower in LiveView since the PDAF functionality is not as complete.

Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11392

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

In Live View, your 650D focuses using the imaging sensor, mainly with contrast-detect AF plus limited on-sensor phase-detect help. That system often has to hunt back and forth to find maximum contrast, so it is slower and can struggle in dim light or on low-contrast subjects.

Through the optical viewfinder, the camera uses its dedicated phase-detect AF sensor. That system can judge focus direction and amount much faster, so it usually locks more quickly and reliably.

So the difference is mainly the AF method: Live View uses sensor-based AF, while viewfinder shooting uses the camera’s dedicated AF module.

To improve Live View AF in low light:

  • focus on an area with strong contrast or clear lines
  • give the camera more light if possible
  • use a wider aperture or shorter focal length if that helps brightness
  • if AF still fails, switch to manual focus
  • consider an external monitor, angle finder, or simply shooting with a wider framing and cropping later when you can’t use the viewfinder

Tapping the screen only chooses the focus area; it does not make low-contrast or dark subjects easier for the AF system to detect.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer