Why have DSLRs traditionally focused faster than mirrorless cameras, and can mirrorless use the same AF system?
Asked 2/3/2015
5 views
2 answers
0
I’ve noticed that DSLRs, when not using Live View, often autofocus faster than older mirrorless cameras. Why is that? What is different about the autofocus systems, and why can’t mirrorless cameras simply use the same autofocus mechanism as a DSLR viewfinder system?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
10
To answer your question directly, I think that your base assumption that Mirrorless AF is slower than DSLR AF is somewhat dated and also unfairly groups cameras that vary a great deal into a single category.
First you must understand the difference between contrast detect AF and phase detect AF. At the end of this answer, you can find more resources on this site related to that question, but I like this summary over at LensRentals.com blog best:
...contrast detection is simpler, cheaper, smaller, and theoretically more accurate than phase detection autofocus. But it is much, much slower. Camera companies are working hard to speed up contrast detection autofocus, and are making some strides, but for the near future it will remain slower.
Vast improvements have been made in the recent year or two that allow Mirrorless cameras to utilize either hybrid systems of AF or essentially the same systems as DSLRs. Early Mirrorless cameras were slow at AF because they used strict contrast-based AF and were not very refined at that. More current Mirrorless cameras, especially from some manufacturers can use phase-detection AF in live view or offer hybrid phase/contrast systems.
To not date this question too much but still give an example, take a look at the Sony A6000, which has 179 point phase detect AF. This advantage should not be overlooked. Having points across the whole sensor vs clumped together in the middle as is the case with DSLRs is a huge advantage especially in action shots. Another big advantage that you can find with mirrorless is the ability to shoot continuously with phase detect AF, saving you the time that a mirror typically has to flip up on a DSLR.
Conclusion
Mirrorless cameras have come a long way from the first few generations in many respects but certainly in autofocus performance. It wasn't until 2013 that phase detect AF really started to appear in Mirrorless cameras, but only a short time later they truly are challenging DSLR autofocus performance. The performance will vary across models so one cannot safely make a statement that all Mirrorless cameras perform a certain way in regards to AF.
Quotes
The best mirrorless cameras match DSLRs for fast autofocus.
...the gap in autofocus performance with the best CSC cameras is closing rapidly.
TheCameraStoreTV(YouTube) -10:04
[Nikon D4S AF] compared to the Panasonic GH4; they are so close I would say they are equal.
More Information
We have quite a few questions already on the site that cover this, but you may need to read multiples of them to really get a good grasp on this subject. Try these:
Originally by user4892. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4892
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Historically, many DSLRs focused faster because they used a dedicated phase-detect autofocus module when shooting through the optical viewfinder. A DSLR’s mirror directs some light down to that separate AF sensor, which can quickly determine not only whether focus is off, but also which direction and roughly how far to move the lens.
Many early mirrorless cameras relied mainly on contrast-detect AF from the imaging sensor. Contrast AF is often very accurate, but it usually has to hunt back and forth to find peak contrast, so it was slower.
Mirrorless cameras generally can’t use the exact same DSLR AF setup because they do not have the mirror/prism arrangement that diverts light to a separate autofocus sensor. Their design sends light straight to the imaging sensor.
That said, the idea that mirrorless is always slower is outdated. Many modern mirrorless cameras use on-sensor phase-detect AF or hybrid AF systems that combine phase and contrast methods, and these can match or exceed DSLR autofocus performance in many situations.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why is autofocus faster on some mirrorless cameras than DSLR live view if both use contrast detect?
Why can DSLR autofocus seem faster than mirrorless autofocus?
Why does my Canon SL1 focus accurately in Live View but miss focus through the viewfinder?
Why is Micro Four Thirds autofocus much faster than DSLR autofocus in live view?
Why is my Canon EOS 750D viewfinder autofocus less accurate than Live View with the 18-55mm kit lens at 18mm?