Why don’t my older Canon-compatible flashes work on the EOS R50 hot shoe?

Asked 6/23/2023

234 views

2 answers

0

I moved from a Canon DSLR to an EOS R50 and found that my existing flash gear no longer works. These flashes worked fine on my Canon DSLRs. Why does this happen on the R50, and what do I need to make older Canon-compatible flashes or triggers work?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

3y ago

2 Answers

7

TL;DR. You need an AD-E1 adapter to use most flash gear with an R50.

The R50's hotshoe is missing all five of the electrical contacts your flash gear needs to communicate with the camera:

top view of the R50's hotshoe

It's using newer edge contacts instead:

front view of the R50's hotshoe showing edge contacts

Welcome to the wacky world of Canon messing with hotshoes. Buckle in, it's a bit of a history lesson.

With the rise of mirrorless, came the rise of video. Flash is useless for video, and a flash hotshoe is a great place to attach video accessories like a microphone, monitor, or small LED lights. But these accessories require cording to ports and power. Sony came up with the idea that instead of using the traditional "floor" contacts/pins that every one (except Minolta) had been using for decades, to add a row of 20 or so small contacts tucked beneath a lip at the back edge of the hotshoe/front edge of the flash foot that could be used to supply power and communicate everything for all these accessories and flashes with the camera. Thus was the Sony multi-interface hotshoe born.

Canon saw what Sony was doing, and when they developed the second generation of EOS R bodies, the R3 had the first multi-function hotshoe. Unlike Sony (who moved from the Minolta iISO hotshoe), Canon could also make their new hotshoe backwards-compatible with older Canon flash gear by retaining the traditional five contacts on the "floor" of the hotshoe, in addition to adding the new edge contacts.

However. Back in the final generation of Canon dSLRs, the three lowest entry-level bodies, the SL3 (250D), T7 (2000D), and T100 (4000D) all had their flash hotshoe sync contact removed. We're not sure why, but the popular theory was to render 3rd-party flashes useless, since that sync contact is how camera tells the flash to fire, and is an ISO standard for flash hotshoes. It didn't even work; Godox got around it with firmware updates (at least for the T7 and T100. With the SL3, they only got their transmitters to be compatible).

But now Canon has gone for total traditional contact removal on the R50. Its hotshoe only has the new multifunction contacts. They probably hope the majority of R50 users will be videographers.

So, at this time, we have three different flash hotshoes on R bodies:

Traditional Canon five-contact hotshoe (like the dSLRs):

traditional hotshoe from R100

  • R
  • RP
  • R5
  • R6
  • R100

Multi function hotshoe that retains the five contacts for backwards compatibility:

R3's hotshoe

  • R3
  • R7
  • R10
  • R6 Mark II
  • R8

The new multi-function hotshoe without the five contacts:

R50 hotshoe

  • R50

Multi-function Stuff

And there is now multi-function-footed Canon flash gear that cannot be used on the traditional dSLR hotshoe because there's no reverse version of the AD-E1 and the foot looks like this:

foot off of the EL-5 with only edge contacts

  • EL-5
  • ST-E10 transmitter
  • OC-E4A off-camera multi-function shoe cord
  • AD-E1 adapter (to put traditional five-pin Canon flash gear onto the multi-function foot and either maintain weathersealing [EL-1, 600EX II-RT) or add compatibility [R50]).

Multi-function footed video gear:

  • DM-E1D microphone
  • AD-P1 smartphone link adapter
  • TASCAM CA-XLR2d-C (XLR microphone adapter, Canon version)

So, to use any traditional Canon flash gear on an R50 hotshoe, like say, Godox gear, 3rd-party radio triggers, or any of the Canon speedlights/triggers other than the EL-5 and ST-E10 (and presumably any future Canon flash gear), you need to use an AD-E1 adapter.

Originally by user27440. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user27440

3y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The EOS R50 uses Canon’s newer multi-function shoe, and unlike older DSLR hot shoes it does not include the traditional five electrical contacts on the shoe surface that most Canon-compatible flashes and radio triggers rely on. That’s why gear that worked on your DSLRs may appear dead or incompatible on the R50.

For most older Canon-compatible flash gear, the fix is Canon’s AD-E1 adapter. It adds the older-style hot-shoe interface so many standard flashes and triggers can communicate normally.

A few things to keep in mind:

  • Accessories designed specifically for the new multi-function shoe may work without an adapter.
  • Older manual single-pin accessories may behave differently depending on the trigger design.
  • Weather sealing and secure fit can vary depending on the flash/adapter combination.

So the short answer is: nothing is necessarily wrong with your flash gear—the R50’s shoe is different. If your flash or trigger expects the classic Canon hot shoe, you’ll usually need the AD-E1 adapter.

UniqueBot

AI

3y ago

Your Answer