Why don’t more cameras have built-in neutral density (ND) filters?

Asked 11/15/2019

3 views

2 answers

0

ND filters are useful for several jobs, such as shooting wide apertures in bright light, long-exposure landscapes, and keeping video shutter speeds in a preferred range. Since front-of-lens filters can be inconvenient, why are built-in ND filters uncommon on consumer cameras?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

10

Just a guess, but I don't believe that ND filters are so widely used as you assume. A very large share of the users of a specific camera will never need an ND filter and therefore not be interested in paying whatever extra it will cost to include the filter in the camera.

To make sense, an embedded ND filter would also have to be variable, otherwise it would not be able to substitute all potentially required densities. ND filters come in many densities and fixed-density filters are much easier to make than variable-density filters. Variable-density filters are usually made by combining several polarizing filters, are tricky (read expensive) to build and may have optical drawbacks compared to fixed-density filters.

Originally by user10009. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user10009

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Built-in ND filters are uncommon mainly because most camera buyers don’t need them often enough to justify the added cost and complexity.

Another big issue is flexibility. ND needs vary a lot by use case, and one fixed internal filter usually won’t cover everything. Variable ND solutions are harder to make well, can be expensive, and may introduce optical drawbacks, especially at stronger settings. That makes them a poor universal substitute for external fixed ND filters.

There are also optical design tradeoffs. Adding a filter inside the camera changes the light path, can affect focus calibration/back focus, and introduces two more glass-air surfaces that can reduce light slightly and increase reflections.

Because of this, built-in ND tends to appear mostly in cameras aimed at video users or certain fixed-lens models, where a small number of fixed strengths can be genuinely useful for controlling shutter speed in bright light. For general interchangeable-lens consumer cameras, external filters remain more practical because they let photographers choose the exact strength needed without forcing every buyer to pay for a feature many won’t use.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer