Why don’t cameras usually offer PNG as a capture format?

Asked 5/5/2011

9 views

2 answers

0

I prefer PNG over JPEG because PNG uses lossless compression. Screenshots and scans often work well as PNG, so why don’t most cameras save photos as PNG too? My camera only offers JPEG, not RAW, and I’m wondering what the technical or practical reasons are for cameras not supporting PNG as an image format.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

66

The JPEG format has the advantage of giving small files. The RAW formats have the advantage of preserving all the data collected at the shot.

The PNG format gives neither of these advantages, so you don't even get a compromise between the other formats, you get almost only the drawbacks from both formats.

Originally by user149. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user149

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

PNG isn’t a popular camera capture format because it misses the main advantages of both JPEG and RAW.

JPEG is used because it makes much smaller files, which saves card space and speeds writing. RAW is used because it preserves the sensor data for later editing. PNG sits awkwardly in between: it is lossless relative to an already processed image, but the camera still has to demosaic, choose white balance, apply sharpening and noise reduction, and reduce bit depth before saving. So compared with RAW, important editing flexibility is already lost.

That means PNG would usually produce files closer in size to RAW, but without RAW’s post-processing benefits. Compared with JPEG, it would be much larger without offering the same practical savings.

Another issue is metadata: JPEG and RAW workflows commonly rely on EXIF data, while PNG has not traditionally had the same standardized EXIF support, which makes it less attractive for camera makers and photographers.

PNG is great for graphics, screenshots, and some scanned material, but for camera photos the usual tradeoff is JPEG for convenience or RAW for maximum image data.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer