Why doesn’t my Nikon D3100 preview exposure changes when I pop up the flash in A or S mode?
Asked 10/15/2012
6 views
2 answers
0
On my Nikon D3100, when I’m shooting in low light and pop up the built-in flash while using Aperture Priority or Shutter Priority, the exposure preview looks almost the same as it does without flash. That makes it seem like the camera doesn’t know the flash will fire. How does the camera expose correctly in these modes if the preview doesn’t change? I’m also seeing some overexposed flash shots and want to better understand how the built-in flash works with the camera’s exposure settings.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
3
That is completely normal. The camera has no idea what the effect of the flash will be and cannot preview it. The effect of flash is extremely variable based on distance and reflectance. For example if you have an object 1m away and one 2m away, the one 2m away gets 4 times less light than the one 1m. Plus, how much it reflects back depends on the object's material and color.
There is no way the camera and similar this without firing the flash which is what modern cameras do before the exposure. This is called TTL Flash which stands for Through The Lens. The camera fires the flash at a low power, measures the results and then adjusts the levels accordingly for the actual shot that follows a fraction of a second later. If you have redeye reduction turned on, the camera will fire 3 times: once to meter, once to contract pupils and once for the exposure.
On some cameras you can fire the pre-flash early and lock in the measured results but I have never seen it update the preview, although technically but if anything in the scene moves, it would no longer be correct. This is called FV-Lock.
For the between the on-board flash and exposure, it depends on the flash mode:
- In Fill mode, the exposure is NOT changed due to flash.
- In Auto Flash mode, exposure is adjusted in consideration based on some measurements of the scene.
- There are other modes (Forced, On, Slow-Sync, Rear-Sync, etc) and how they behave differs between cameras, so read the manual and conduct a few experiments with a static scene.
Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1620
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—this is normal. The live preview/viewfinder preview generally cannot show the real effect of flash before the shot, because flash exposure depends on things the camera can’t fully predict in advance, such as subject distance, background distance, and how reflective surfaces are.
On cameras like the D3100, flash exposure is typically handled with TTL metering: the camera fires a brief pre-flash, measures the light through the lens, and then sets flash output for the actual exposure a fraction of a second later. That’s how it can expose correctly even though the preview doesn’t visibly change much.
In A mode, the camera mainly adjusts shutter speed for ambient light; in S mode, it mainly adjusts aperture. The flash is then added on top of that exposure. If your shots are overexposed, the built-in flash may simply be too direct or strong for the scene. A hot-shoe flash usually gives better results, especially if you can bounce it, since that makes the light softer and more natural.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Nikon D3100 flash fires even when the pop-up flash is down
Why does the Nikon D7000 pop-up flash still show up in Commander mode set to "--"?
Why won’t the Nikon D3100 flash pop up automatically in low light?
How do I avoid overexposure with the Nikon D7000 pop-up flash in Manual mode?
Can a Nikon D5200 use continuous burst mode with the built-in pop-up flash?