Why doesn’t a zoom lens get darker as you zoom in?
Asked 7/25/2018
5 views
2 answers
0
If increasing focal length means a narrower angle of view, it seems like fewer photons should reach the sensor. So why doesn’t the image usually look darker in the viewfinder when you zoom in? And why don’t telephoto focal lengths automatically require longer shutter speeds than wide-angle focal lengths at the same f-stop?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
32
The answer to this question revolves around explaining how zoom lenses function because you are correct in your observation: As you zoom to higher and higher magnifications the image dims unless somehow compensation is applied. Suppose you zoom from 25mm to 50mm, should the working diameter of the aperture remain unchanged, image brightness would suffer a 4x loss as to its intensity. Stated differently, each doubling of the focal length will dim, it will be just 25% as bright as it was before the zoom. If true, how is this light loss prevented?
The amount of light energy that can enter the lens is directly related to the working diameter of the iris diaphragm (aperture). The larger the working diameter the more surface area, the more light the lens can gather.
The modern zoom lens has a trick up its sleeve that keeps the image brightness the same thorough most of the zoom. Some high end zooms keep the image brightness throughout the zoom. How this works: The diameter of the aperture as seen when looking into the lens from the front appears larger than it actually is. This is because the front group of lens elements of the zoom lens magnifies thus the diameter of this entrance circle appears larger than reality.
Further, as you zoom, the distance from the front lens group and the iris diaphragm also change. This induces an apparent diameter change. The fact that it is apparent and not a real change is unimportant. From the outside looking in, this change appears real and this action allows more and more light energy to enter as you zoom.
As I said earlier, some high end zooms are good to go through the entire zoom. These are called constant aperture zooms. Lower priced zooms keep a constant aperture until the last 80% or so of the zoom, these fail and suffer the light loss you are asking about.
Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user44949
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Because exposure depends on light per unit area at the sensor, not the total light gathered from the whole scene.
The key is the f-number: f/stop = focal length ÷ effective aperture diameter (entrance pupil). If a zoom lens keeps the same f-number as you zoom in, the entrance pupil also gets larger in proportion to focal length. Double the focal length, and the entrance pupil diameter must double, giving 4× the area and offsetting the 4× loss from spreading the image over a larger projection.
So at the same f-stop, a 50mm lens and a 100mm lens give the same exposure for the same scene brightness, even though the 100mm shows a narrower field of view.
If the entrance pupil did stay the same size while zooming, the image would get darker. That’s exactly what happens with variable-aperture zooms at their maximum aperture: for example, a lens might be f/3.5 at the wide end and f/5.6 at the long end.
So telephoto lenses don’t inherently need longer shutter speeds because of focal length alone—only if their maximum aperture becomes smaller.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why can a 17–35mm lens be physically much longer than its focal length?
Do any zoom lenses or hoods use adjustable petals to match focal length?
Can wide-angle lenses work well for portraits of children and babies?
How do you calculate magnification when stacking one lens on another for macro photography?
Why does my Canon 500D kit lens struggle to autofocus at longer zoom settings?