Why doesn’t a leaf shutter overexpose the center of the image?
Asked 12/16/2021
2 views
2 answers
0
I understand how a focal-plane shutter can give each part of the sensor the same exposure time as the slit travels across the frame. But with a leaf shutter, it seems like the center opens first, stays open longest, and closes last. Wouldn’t that mean the center of the frame gets more light than the edges, creating a radial exposure gradient? If not, why not? Did film cameras or digital cameras need any compensation for this?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
4y ago
2 Answers
16
There are actually a variety of leaf shutter designs, so a single answer might not be entirely appropriate... but it seems apparent that you are talking about the in-lens aperture diaphragm type.
There is an error in your understanding. The central light path does not expose the central portion of the sensor/negative... e.g. using a small f-stop does not result in a small circular image in the middle of the image area. Instead, the image circle remains the same size and is limited by the lens barrel.
The first thing to understand is that there is all of the light required to create a complete image at every point on the objective lens; i.e. the light from every point in a scene spreads out and hits every point on the lens.
And aperture adjustment is really just changing the exposure by the stacking of multiple images upon the image plane (fewer/more). This type of leaf shutter does not cause mechanical vignetting... the only mechanical vignetting will occur at max apertures where images taken from the edge of the objective element are included; and those images include the edge of the lens barrel (which causes the shading; and is cured by stopping down).
Some other types of leaf shutters can cause mechanical/optical vignetting if they are outside of the lens assembly (more like a focal plane shutter or apodization filter).
Some lens designs can suffer from natural vignetting due to the inverse square law (cosine fourth law) where the light from far off-center portions of the scene have to converge at the center of a small diameter lens and then spread back out widely over a short distance in order to cover the image area... Basically, wide angle lenses with short flange distances are most susceptible. But it is not caused by, nor cured by, stopping down an aperture restriction.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
4y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
No—under normal operation, a leaf shutter does not make the center of the frame brighter simply because it opens from the middle.
The key point is that the shutter blades sit inside the lens, so while opening and closing they act more like an aperture than like a moving slit at the sensor. A smaller aperture does not form a small bright circle in the middle of the image; it still illuminates the whole image area, just with less light. The same idea applies to a leaf shutter during its travel.
Light from each scene point passes through many parts of the lens, and each point on the image is formed by light passing through the lens opening as a whole. So partially open shutter blades reduce the amount of light reaching the entire frame rather than exposing only the center.
For typical shutter speeds, this produces essentially even exposure across the frame, aside from normal lens vignetting. No special film-era or digital compensation is generally needed for a center-brightness effect.
One caveat: at very fast shutter speeds, the opening/closing phase can affect the effective aperture during the exposure, which can slightly influence depth of field or exposure behavior, but not in the simple “bright center, dark edges” way described.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI4y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do focal-plane shutters use a moving slit at fast shutter speeds instead of exposing the whole sensor at once?
Why did some Graflex cameras use both a focal-plane shutter and a leaf shutter?
Why can’t a normal flash exceed X-sync just by staying on during shutter travel?
How does electronic first-curtain shutter work with a mechanical second curtain?
Can I make the Panasonic FZ300 EVF/LCD stay bright while using exposure bracketing?