Why does the sky look noisy and the distant hill soft in my Nikon D600 landscape photo?
Asked 1/7/2020
3 views
2 answers
0
I shot a landscape with a Nikon D600 and noticed two problems: the blue sky looks grainy/noisy even at low ISO (around 400), and the distant hill seems a bit soft even though that was my focus point. The camera would not focus on the sky. What causes this, and what could I do differently when shooting or editing to improve the result?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
3
Blue skies are typically noisy with any camera, and at any ISO. It is due to the RGB filtration of the individual photosites/pixels.
With the common Bayer filter array 50% of the photosites are filtered to a green centric wavelength, and 25% are filtered to blue and red centric wavelengths (each). So when you photograph a blue sky only 25% of the photosites are optimal for recording the scene.
But note that I said "color centric" wavelengths; because there is typically some overlap (varies by camera). So even if the sky was a pure uniform blue, some green and red photosites may still collect enough light to generate a notable response.
What this means is that; a uniform blue sky can be very confusing for the demosaicing algorithm to work with and results in color noise (typically red/magenta IME). This is very similar to recording very dark scenes where random photosites collect enough light to generate a more significant response resulting in random color noise.
Your image does lack sharpness... my best guess is that it is due to camera movement due to working with low ISO's (longer exposure times). It is also likely at least partially due to atmospheric interference over long distances (moisture, haze, heat, etc).
Edit to add: The response curves are for the D300 sensor with the IR filter removed, and show a higher sensitivity in the IR range outside of visible light (above 740) than a standard camera would exhibit.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A noisy blue sky is common in digital photos, even at relatively low ISO. With a Bayer sensor, only a portion of the pixels are primarily recording blue light, so smooth blue skies can show color noise and demosaicing artifacts more easily than other subjects.
The camera also won’t usually autofocus on a plain sky because it lacks contrast. For a landscape, focus on a distant high-contrast object at a similar distance, or use manual focus.
If the hill looks soft, it may be from focus placement, slight atmospheric haze, or simply not enough depth of field depending on aperture and distance.
What to do:
- Use the lowest practical ISO.
- Focus on a distant contrast edge, not the sky itself.
- Stop down appropriately for more depth of field if needed.
- Shoot RAW and apply noise reduction selectively to the sky.
- In editing, mask the sky and smooth/reduce noise there only.
- For very high-contrast scenes, consider blending multiple exposures/composite shots for sky and ground.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why do my night cityscape photos look noisy and not perfectly sharp?
Why do some of my 400-speed black-and-white film scans look grainy and soft?
How can I avoid sky banding/posterization when denoising RAW files in Darktable?
Why do my Fujifilm S8200 photos look grainy and soft indoors, and how can I improve them?
Can I improve landscape shots from a compact camera, or is a larger-sensor camera necessary?
