Why does the Canon 500D only let me set full-stop ISO values manually?

Asked 7/19/2011

2 views

2 answers

0

On my Canon 500D, aperture and shutter speed can be adjusted in 1/3-stop steps, but manual ISO only offers full stops like 100, 200, 400, and 800. However, when ISO is set to Auto, the camera sometimes displays intermediate values such as ISO 150 or 320. Why can’t I choose these partial ISO values manually? Is this just a limitation of the 500D, or is there a technical reason behind it?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

15

Analogue amplification (pre-digitization) is the best way to implement a variable ISO sensitivity. When you do so you are only amplifying the photon noise. When you amplify the digital data (i.e. by multiplying all the values by a fixed amount) you amplify the photon noise, the read noise and the quantization noise, leading to more noise overall!

Most Canon DSLRs only have analogue amplification circuits for the whole stops (100, 200, 400, 800 etc.), when you select one of the intermediate fractional values (520, 640 etc.) uses the closest analogue amplification stop and then uses digital multiplication to give the correct overall sensitivity. E.g. ISO640 is really ISO800 multiplied by 0.8, ISO500 is really ISO400 multiplied by 1.25 etc.

This is bad as you either end up using a higher analogue ISO and lose highlight headroom, or a lower analogue ISO and get more noise than necessary. For this reason I would advise against using the fractional stops on Cameras that support it.

For an example of how bad digital amplification can be compared to analogue, see this image:

The top image was shot at f/2.8 1/30s and at ISO1600, i.e. 5 stops of analogue amplification. The bottom image was shot at an identical f/2.8 1/30s but ISO100, and then 5 stops of digital amplification were applied in Photoshop. The result is that digital amplification gives a lot more noise.

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

On the 500D, this is mainly a model/firmware limitation: Canon only gives you manual access to full-stop ISO values on that camera, while some higher-end bodies offer 1/3-stop ISO control.

There’s also a technical reason often cited for Canon DSLRs of that era: the camera’s “native” analog gain steps are typically the full stops (100, 200, 400, 800, etc.). Intermediate ISO values may be created by taking the nearest full-stop analog gain and then applying digital scaling. That can be less optimal for noise than using true analog gain alone.

So the camera can show intermediate ISO values in Auto ISO, but Canon chose not to expose 1/3-stop ISO selection manually on the 500D. In short: yes, it’s largely a feature limitation of that entry-level model, and partly related to how intermediate ISO values are implemented.

If you specifically want manual 1/3-stop ISO control, you’d typically need a higher-end/newer body, or use unofficial firmware at your own risk.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer