Why does rotating a polarizing filter make a rainbow fade or stand out more?

Asked 9/12/2018

2 views

2 answers

0

When I rotate a polarizing filter while photographing a rainbow, one position can make the rainbow nearly disappear, while another makes it much stronger—sometimes strong enough to reveal a secondary rainbow I can’t see with the naked eye. Why does this happen, and is there a simple way to visualize it?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

6

The obvious answer is that the light from a rainbow, or at least the portion that is fitting in your viewfinder at the time you are rotating the polarizer, is all polarized in the same direction.¹ That is, the light reflecting off of millions of water droplets falling in the atmosphere is polarized in the same way by the more or less uniform shape of those droplets as they fall.

That explains how it can be blocked, but how is it enhanced by the lens?

When you rotate a polarizer you are changing the direction of the polarized light that is filtered out. What is left is easier to see since the competing light polarized in a different direction is no longer making it through the filter.

It's not really enhanced, as in 'increased', by the filter. But when competing light polarized in a different direction is eliminated, what is left is easier to see. It's the same way polarized sunglasses work. By filtering out bright glare, one can see details that were already present, but being drowned out by the glare.

¹ As scottbb points out in a comment, if an entire rainbow from horizon to horizon is wide enough, and the lens' field of view is wide enough to see all of it at once, the polarizer won't affect the entire rainbow equally for any single position of the polarizer.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Rainbows are strongly polarized. As sunlight is refracted and reflected inside many raindrops, the rainbow light that reaches you tends to vibrate mostly in one plane.

A circular or linear polarizing filter works by passing light of one polarization more than the perpendicular polarization. When you rotate the filter, you change which polarization is transmitted and which is blocked.

So:

  • in one orientation, the filter blocks much of the rainbow’s polarized light, making the rainbow fade or disappear
  • in the opposite orientation, it passes more of the rainbow while reducing other polarized glare and scattered light in the scene

The filter is not really making the rainbow brighter; it is improving contrast by removing competing light, so the rainbow appears stronger. That extra contrast can make a secondary rainbow visible even when your eye barely notices it.

A simple visualization is to imagine light waves vibrating in many directions, while the rainbow’s light is mostly aligned in one direction. Rotating the polarizer is like rotating a picket fence: waves aligned with the openings pass through, while waves at the blocked angle are reduced.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer