Why does phone flash make brass look gray or pink indoors?
Asked 1/30/2021
7 views
2 answers
0
I photographed some brass items indoors with an older Samsung Android phone. The two shots were taken 8 seconds apart with the same composition; the only change was turning the flash on. Without flash, the brass looks warm and natural. With flash, the brass looks dull gray and some other parts take on a pink/rose tint.
The room had fluorescent tubes and an LED work light, and the phone was set to auto white balance and auto exposure. EXIF shows the flash shot used a faster shutter speed and lower ISO than the non-flash shot.
Why would adding flash make brass lose its yellow color instead of making it pop more?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
14
My assumption is that the auto white balance took over.
The image, because you took the photo pretty close is dark everywhere except the brass. If the auto white balance is turned on, the warm tint of it was turned into a neutral color, gray.
See if it is the case. Take a test photo with white paper below. The camera will notice this white and use it to balance the white, leaving the brass alone.
Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user37321
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Most likely this is a white-balance / phone image-processing issue triggered by the flash and mixed indoor lighting.
With flash enabled, the phone changed exposure significantly (faster shutter, lower ISO) and probably recalculated auto white balance. Brass is a warm, reflective subject, so the camera may have tried to neutralize that warmth, pushing the brass toward gray while shifting other tones pink/rose. Phone processing can also apply aggressive color correction when it detects flash and mixed light sources like fluorescent + LED.
A simpler explanation than “bad brass under flash” is that the camera’s automatic processing is being fooled by the scene.
What to try:
- lock or manually set white balance if your camera app allows it
- avoid mixing flash with fluorescent/LED room lights
- add a neutral reference (like white paper) in a test shot so auto white balance has something neutral to read
- try a different camera app or phone if the result looks like an unwanted filter effect
So the flash itself isn’t inherently making brass gray; the phone’s auto color/exposure processing under mixed lighting is the likely cause.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I get sharper focus and more natural color in simple product photography with a Canon T2i?
How can I improve RAW photos shot under fluorescent light in Lightroom?
Why do product photos vary in brightness with manual camera and strobe settings?
Why do my Pentax ME Portra 400 scans look white, grainy, and washed out indoors?
Why did one of my film photos come out dull, gray, and low-contrast while another taken moments earlier looked fine?