Why does my camera expose two flower shots differently—does subject color affect metering?

Asked 9/9/2012

5 views

2 answers

0

I shot two different flowers on a Nikon D5100 using Portrait mode. One image came out with a nicely dark background, while the other looked brighter overall and the flower seemed overexposed. Repeating the shots gave the same result.

Can subject color cause the camera to choose a different exposure, or is it really reacting to brightness/tonality and lighting? What is the correct technical term for this, and how can I compensate when the camera’s automatic exposure doesn’t match what I want?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

5

When your camera adjusts your settings (aperture, shutter speed, and/or ISO) to get a certain exposure value it is basing those decisions on the tone of the image (different from color).

It could be any color, but the tone should average out to be 18% grey (thus the use of grey cards that are 18% grey). So if you had a bright white vs a dark white you would experience the same issues as you would bright green vs dark green.

If you have an image that is supposed to be predominately bright then the camera will darken it to reach 18% grey so you need to adjust your exposure to be brighter to compensate. Conversely, if your image is predominately dark the camera will brighten your image to get to 18% grey and so you need to lower your target exposure to fool the camera into getting the correct exposure.

This is why people use manual. If you are shooting a light skinned person with blonde hair and a white shirt against a dark background and that person takes up most of the frame the camera will darken the image and you can set your target exposure (Av and Tv modes) to get the correct brightness. However, if you move forward, backwards, or side to side and change how much of the frame your model takes up in the picture then it can change how your camera calculates the exposure. Using manual this won't happen (the meter will bounce around as it predicts changes, but the meter in manual mode is just a guide and doesn't actually do anything).

In your case the white flower is bright so the camera darkens the whole frame to reach 18% grey, thus the darker than normal background. In the case of the red flower, the flower was darker so it made the whole frame brighter which raises the background to be overexposed as well.

Originally by user9510. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user9510

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—what you’re seeing is mainly a metering/exposure issue, and it’s driven more by scene brightness (tone/luminance) than color alone.

Camera meters try to make the scene average out to roughly a midtone, often described as 18% gray. So:

  • a mostly bright subject/background may be darkened by the camera
  • a mostly dark scene may be brightened by the camera

That’s why two flowers can meter differently even in the same mode. Lighting also matters a lot: a white flower lit from the side can push the camera to protect highlights, while a more evenly lit flower/background may meter brighter overall.

On some cameras, including Nikon DSLRs, the meter can also use color information as part of its scene analysis, but tone and lighting are the main factors.

The technical terms are exposure metering or reflective metering. To fix it, use exposure compensation:

  • dial in negative compensation if the camera is making the scene too bright
  • dial in positive compensation if it’s making the scene too dark

You can also meter from a neutral area or use a gray card for more consistent exposure.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer