Why does my APS-C Canon still show 400mm with a 70-200mm and 2x extender?

Asked 4/6/2014

7 views

2 answers

0

I’m using the same lens setup on two Canon bodies:

  • Canon 5D Mark III + 70-200mm + 2x extender
  • Canon 450D + 70-200mm + 2x extender

In both cases the EXIF in Lightroom reports a maximum focal length of 400mm. I often read that a crop-sensor body gives “extra reach,” and that a lens behaves like a longer lens on APS-C.

So why doesn’t the crop body show more than 400mm? Does the APS-C camera actually give more reach, or is it just cropping the image compared to full frame?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

2

Try this: Take the same picture from the same spot with each camera and the 70-200mm lens + 2X extender. You will see that the angle of view is narrower for the APS-C camera than the Full Frame camera. If both images are then displayed at the same size, the image from the APS-C camera will have been magnified to a greater degree than the image from the FF camera. That is what the article you linked to in your question is referring to: images from cameras with smaller sensors must be magnified to a greater degree than images from a larger sensor to reach the same display size.

Another way to look at it: take the image from the 5D mark III and crop it so that only the part that was captured by the center 40% of the sensor (that equates to an APS-C sized sensor). Then display it at the same size as the full image. You will see that it looks like the cropped print was zoomed in by a factor of 1.6x. What you give up in the case of cropping the same image is resolution. The original file is 21.1MP, the cropped image is about 8.24MP. That is lower resolution than your 12MP APS-C 450D.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The lens is still 400mm on both cameras. EXIF reports the actual focal length of the lens/extender combination, not the “full-frame equivalent.”

What changes on APS-C is the field of view. Because the sensor is smaller, it captures a narrower portion of the image circle, so the scene looks more tightly framed. That’s why people say it gives “more reach.”

A simple way to think about it: the APS-C image is similar to taking the full-frame image and cropping to the center, then enlarging it to the same display size. The lens is not becoming longer; the camera is just recording a smaller area.

So:

  • 70-200mm + 2x extender = 140-400mm on both cameras
  • On the 450D, the framing is narrower than on the 5D Mark III
  • Lightroom still correctly shows 400mm, because that is the real focal length

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer