Why does focus seem to shift when zooming my Sony 18-105mm lens?
Asked 9/24/2014
2 views
2 answers
0
Using a Sony E-mount 18-105mm constant-aperture zoom on a NEX-5R, I focused manually at 18mm and then zoomed to 105mm without refocusing. The image became noticeably soft. But if I focused manually at 105mm first and then zoomed out to 18mm, the image still looked sharp.
Does this mean the lens is varifocal only when zooming in and parfocal when zooming out? Or is the difference just depth of field?
I was shooting at f/8, ISO 200, aperture priority, with a 2-second timer. I also noticed that cropping the 18mm image looked sharper than taking the same scene at 105mm after zooming without refocusing. Why would that be?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
16
The lens is not parfocal in either direction.
What you have discovered is the difference between narrow Depth of Field (DoF) at longer focal lengths and deeper Depth of Field at wider focal lengths. The focusing error you introduce when you focus at 18mm and then zoom to 105mm is greater than the shallow DoF at 105mm even at f/8, so you notice how out of focus the photo is. The focusing error you introduce when you focus at 105mm and then zoom to 18mm is well within the DoF at 18mm and f/8 because the focusing distance is much greater than the hyperfocal distance for 18mm @ f/8.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The lens is not parfocal in either direction. When you zoom, focus shifts.
What makes it seem one-sided is depth of field. At 18mm and f/8, depth of field is much deeper, so a focus error caused by zooming may still fall within acceptable sharpness. At 105mm and f/8, depth of field is much shallower, so the same focus shift becomes obvious.
So if you focus at 105mm and zoom out, the image can still look sharp because the wider focal length masks the error. If you focus at 18mm and zoom in, the longer focal length reveals the error.
That also explains why a crop from the 18mm shot can look sharper than a 105mm shot taken after zooming without refocusing: the 18mm image was correctly focused at 18mm, while the 105mm image was no longer in focus after the zoom.
In practice, with a varifocal lens, refocus after zooming. If you want the most critical focus, checking focus at the longer focal length is still useful because shallow depth of field makes errors easier to see.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I tell whether a zoom lens is parfocal, and are these Canon and Sigma zooms parfocal?
Why do my Nikon D5100 kit lens photos look out of focus after I zoom back out?
Why doesn’t exposure change much when I zoom in at the same f-number?
Why do shutter speed and exposure change when zooming in on a Canon A800 in Sunset mode?
Why does a zoom lens give shallower background blur at 105mm f/5.6 than at 18mm f/3.5?