Why does focus fall off near the top and bottom of a frame?

Asked 7/9/2017

4 views

2 answers

0

In a film still, the image appears sharp in the center but loses focus near the top and bottom edges. What optical issue can cause this kind of edge softness, and could it come from the taking lens or from later film scanning/digitizing?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

5

This is most likely caused by field curvature. Whether it was introduced when the footage was shot or later when the film was digitized or even when converted to the still image above is impossible to say from only looking at the sample image above.

At the time Rooster Cogburn was filmed plenty of lenses did not correct very much for field curvature. This might particularly be the case for lenses selected by a cinematographer for use to film mostly outdoors in daylight the way most westerns were shot.

In the 1970s budget considerations were often tighter for westerns than other types of films. The marquee value of the actors, rather than pure cinemagraphic quality, drove the box office performance of a genre that was fast falling out of favor with the moviegoing public. With the fairly narrow apertures used in daylight shooting conditions the effects of field curvature could be largely ignored. The photo above, however, was likely a single 24x16mm frame from footage shot in a much dimmer environment to simulate an indoor scene and the aperture would have probably been opened up more than would normally have been the case for most of the other scenes in the film.

Although as of late field curvature seems to most photographers to have become an undesired aberration to be avoided at all costs when considering a new lens, there are times when it is a desired quality for getting a shot to look a certain way. For the photographers who are in the know about what such a lens can do for certain types of shots field curvature isn't necessarily a problem at all.

The demise of the attractiveness of lenses with field curvature seems to be the current obsession with how sharply a lens can photograph a flat test chart as seemingly the only criteria upon which to base a judgement of a lens' quality. When the center is in best focus, a lens with field curvature will look softer on the edges. That doesn't mean, however, that the lens is really 'soft' on the edges. It just means that when aiming at a flat test chart with the center of the chart in sharpest focus the focus distance at the edges is somewhere in front of the surface of the chart. With some very high quality lenses that are designed to have field curvature, the edges of a flat test chart can be rendered very sharply by adjusting the focus distance. Of course this makes the center of the flat test chart slightly out of focus and now the center looks a bit soft!

In the case of the example image in the question, the field curvature appears to have an oval, rather than circular shape. This would indicate that the lens used to film the scene and any lenses used to convert the film to a later format were anamorphic lenses.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A likely cause is field curvature. With field curvature, the lens does not focus onto a perfectly flat plane, so if the center is in focus, areas toward the edges can fall out of focus.

That was more common with many older lenses, including cinema lenses from the 1970s, especially if ultimate edge-to-edge correction was not the top priority. In a movie frame, this can show up as softer focus near the top and bottom while the middle looks sharp.

It is also possible the effect was introduced or exaggerated later in the chain: during film duplication, transfer, scanning, digitizing, or even in a still frame extraction. From a single sample image, you usually cannot tell with certainty whether the softness came from the original lens or from later processing.

So the short answer is: edge focus falloff like this is often due to field curvature, but with film material it could also be caused by the way the image was transferred or digitized.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer