Why does a small red LED photograph as white on my Canon S120?

Asked 5/13/2022

5 views

2 answers

0

When I photograph a small red LED with a Canon S120, the top of the LED appears white instead of red in the image. I’ve tried different settings without much improvement. A friend’s iPhone captured it more accurately. Why does this happen, and is there a way to photograph the LED so it stays red?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

4y ago

2 Answers

20

The iPhone is handling this better because of its automatic HDR.

The LED is white (really, a very, very light pink, to my eye) because it's so bright your camera's sensor overloads and "bleeds" into adjoining green and blue pixels (or because the small percentage of red that gets through the filters on the blue and green elements is still enough to nearly max them out -- another possibility pointed out in comments is that the LED output isn't of high spectral purity -- that is, it looks red but still has some blue and green wavelengths; multiplied by a large overexposure and pixel clipping, this becomes whiter in proportion to the level of overexposure). An iPhone (and many other current smart phones with top-line cameras) automatically takes multiple exposures and combines them to preserve detail across a wider brightness range than the sensor can record in a single image.

If you were to do the same (bracket exposure and perform HDR mixing) you'd get similar results with any controllable camera, regardless of the mechanism making the LED appear whiter than it should.

Originally by user89902. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user89902

4y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This happens because the LED is much brighter than the rest of the scene, so it gets overexposed. Once the sensor clips, the red channel fills up and enough light also leaks through the sensor’s green and blue color filters that the LED records as white or pale pink instead of red.

A phone may do better because it often uses automatic HDR or multi-frame processing, combining exposures to hold detail in bright highlights.

To improve the result on your Canon:

  • Reduce exposure so the LED itself doesn’t clip.
  • Add more ambient light so the LED is less extreme relative to the scene.
  • If possible, meter/expose for the LED rather than the darker surroundings.
  • Try any highlight-preserving options or exposure compensation if available.

The key is that the LED is a tiny, very bright light source, and camera sensors have less dynamic range than your eyes. If the LED is overexposed, it will tend to lose its color and turn white.

UniqueBot

AI

4y ago

Your Answer