Why does a flash make a popping sound and puff of air when a modifier is held very close?

Asked 1/29/2013

1 views

2 answers

0

When I hold a small object like a piece of cardboard about 1–2 cm in front of a camera’s pop-up flash, I hear a soft “pop” when the flash fires and can feel a slight tap on the cardboard. The flash isn’t touching it, just very close.

What causes that sound and the little puff/tap? Also, is it bad for the flash to hold objects that close in front of it?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

10

To put it simply; the gas inside the flash tube gets very hot very quickly. (The flash tube itself will get very hot if the flash power and duration are long enough.) That causes the gas to expand rapidly, "hammering" on the flash tube. If the tube itself gets significantly hotter, that will add to the shock wave created in the air around the tube. It's the hammering that makes the pop, but there is also heat transferred to the air around the tube that can cause nearby membranes to react to the pressure.

When I was using large format cameras, very small apertures, slow film and very powerful studio strobes (several 2400 Joule heads within a light bank), it wasn't unusual for a subject to feel a puff of air at a distance of several feet. Not quite at the "vortex cannon" level, but a bit disturbing to some folks nonetheless. (Being in front of a camera is scary enough for most people; having the process literally hit you between the eyes does nothing for composure.) Part of that was the effect described above, and part of it was a very slight increase in temperature right at the surface of their skin causing some overpressure in the boundary layer of air around them.

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The pop is caused by the flash tube heating its gas extremely quickly when it fires. That rapid heating makes the gas expand suddenly, creating a small pressure wave in the air—basically a tiny puff/shock wave. When something like cardboard is very close, you can hear that as a soft “pop” and feel it as a slight tap.

Some of the effect can also come from heat transferred to the nearby air, which briefly pushes on the object in front of the flash.

So the sound and tap are normal physical effects of a flash discharge, especially when an object is held very close to the tube.

As for whether it’s bad: keeping material extremely close to a flash can increase heat buildup, and flash tubes can get hot enough to matter, especially at higher power or with repeated firing. An occasional quick test is unlikely to be a problem, but routinely placing objects 1–2 cm from the flash is not a great idea. Leave some space and avoid blocking ventilation or exposing materials to unnecessary heat.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer