Why do some DSLR cameras disable or limit autofocus at small maximum apertures like f/5.6 or f/8?
Asked 10/7/2011
1 views
2 answers
0
On some Canon and Nikon DSLRs, autofocus is reduced or disabled when the lens-and-teleconverter combination has a maximum aperture smaller than certain limits, often around f/5.6, with some higher-end bodies supporting limited AF at f/8. Other brands may still attempt AF beyond that point, even if it becomes slow or unreliable. Why do Canon and Nikon impose these autofocus limits instead of simply trying to focus with reduced performance?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
24
Aperture limitations are a consequence of the design of phase detect autofocus systems and are not specific to Canon.
Phase detect autofocus in SLRs works by directing light to the AF sensor using a second mirror behind the semi-silvered main mirror. The AF sensor uses a pair of lenses to focus light from the subject onto a pair of 1-dimensional sensors, effectively lines of pixels. By measuring the offset between contrast patterns measured on each sensor the distance to the subject can be calculated. See this crude diagram (not to scale!)
The size and separation between the pair of AF sensors determines the accuracy of the AF measurement. However there is a trade off - the further apart they are, the wider the aperture must be in order to direct light to reach both sensors. In the diagram I have included an aperture stop that represents, say f/4.0 (the lens is f/2.8 wide open). With the lens stopped down to f/4.0 incoming light would be blocked from reaching the AF sensors.
Modern AF units have multiple AF points, each composed of a pair sensors at different separations and orientations. The centre point often has an extra wide separation sensor pair and thus only works at maximum accuracy at f/2.8. Often AF points have pairs of 1D pixels at 90 degrees in order to detect either horizontal or vertical detail. One pixel row will have greater separation so the AF point only works as a "cross type" sensor when using a large aperture lens, otherwise either the vertical or horizontal sensor is disabled, leaving a regular single-orientation AF point.
The sensors may work a bit past their specified aperture, as the pattern of light might overlap the sensor just enough to get a match and calculate the distance, which is why taping the pins of a teleconverter sometimes works. But in general it's not designed to do this so to prevent inaccurate or intermittent performance, Canon disable AF when the reported aperture is too small.
Canon has optimised their AF units to be very accurate with wide aperture lenses (which Canon offers at even long focal lengths, for example the 400mm f/2.8 or 600mm f/4.0), rather than to be more flexible continuing to work but with less speed and accuracy at small apertures.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Because DSLR phase-detect autofocus has physical limits tied to lens aperture. In an SLR, part of the light is sent by the mirror system to a dedicated AF sensor. That sensor compares light from opposite sides of the lens to detect focus. For this to work, the AF point’s sensor elements need enough light and enough separation across the lens opening.
Wider-aperture lenses provide the light path geometry needed for more accurate AF, including cross-type and high-precision points. As the maximum aperture gets smaller, some AF points can no longer function as designed, and accuracy and reliability drop sharply. So the camera is usually not “artificially” restricting AF; it is preventing unreliable focus operation.
Some cameras will still attempt AF past these limits, but performance may become very slow or inconsistent. Canon and Nikon generally choose conservative cutoffs to maintain dependable autofocus behavior. On certain higher-end bodies, limited f/8 autofocus is supported, typically with fewer AF points (often the center point only), because those systems are designed to handle the reduced light and geometry better.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which autofocus points on the Nikon D750 work at f/8?
How can you force autofocus with a Canon teleconverter, and what are the trade-offs?
Will autofocus work on a Canon 600D with a 70-200mm f/4 and a 2x teleconverter?
Which Nikon teleconverter is the best compromise for a D800 with the 80-400mm VR and 105mm f/2.8 Micro while keeping autofocus?
Why can mirrorless cameras autofocus with very slow lenses like f/11 or f/16?
