Why do some Canon lenses stay wide open off-camera while many Nikon lenses stop down when removed?
Asked 7/24/2013
202 views
2 answers
0
I’ve noticed that some Canon lenses remain at their widest aperture when removed from the camera, while many Nikon lenses appear to stop down as soon as they come off the body. Why do lenses from different systems behave differently when detached? Is it mainly due to mechanical design, electronic control, or just tradition?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
17
Both systems (and all others that set the aperture via the camera body) will set the aperture wide open when a lens is attached to the camera, to provide the brightest view possible in the viewfinder and to facilitate manual focusing.
Canon EOS lenses uses an electronic iris. A signal is sent to the lens to close the iris when taking a photo or using DOF preview. Since the aperture is wide open most of the time, the camera or lens would have to detect removal of the lens and send a signal to the aperture control motor, which is extra work for no benefit.
Nikkor lenses use a mechanical coupling which is spring loaded. Removing the lens means the camera body coupling is no longer pushing the aperture control lever, meaning it springs back, closing the aperture. Designing the system to avoid this would probably have been additional work, again for no real reason.
In summary any slight advantage to having the aperture open or closed when the lens is not mounted is dwarfed by he design effort involved due to the different approach of mechanical vs electronic control, so the manufacturers did what was easiest.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
It’s mainly a design difference in how the aperture is controlled.
On SLR systems, lenses are normally held wide open while mounted so the viewfinder stays bright and focusing is easier. The aperture only closes to the selected f-stop at the moment of exposure or when using depth-of-field preview.
Many Nikon F-mount lenses use a mechanical, spring-loaded aperture lever. When the lens is removed, the camera body is no longer holding that lever in the wide-open position, so the spring returns the iris toward a stopped-down position.
Canon EF/EOS lenses use electronic aperture control. The lens stays wide open unless the camera sends a command to stop it down. Once removed, there’s usually no reason to send a special “close down” command, so it commonly remains open. Some adapters or camera firmware can choose to close the aperture on power-off, which shows this is largely about control design rather than optics.
So the difference is mostly mechanical vs. electronic aperture actuation, not image quality or a universal brand rule.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do full-stop ISO settings give better image quality on Canon DSLRs?
Why do adapted manual lenses overexpose on Canon DSLRs when stopped down, and how can I work around it?
Why do some stabilized lenses make a constant noise when the camera is on?
How do you control aperture and metering when reversing a Nikon G lens?
Are intermediate ISO settings real analog gain or digital processing?