Why do adapted manual lenses overexpose on Canon DSLRs when stopped down, and how can I work around it?

Asked 4/13/2012

1 views

2 answers

0

I'm using Contax/Yashica manual-focus lenses on Canon DSLRs via chipped adapters that provide focus confirmation. Exposure is reasonable wide open, but as soon as I stop the lens down, Av-mode metering becomes increasingly inaccurate and tends to overexpose, sometimes by a couple of stops.

I've seen this on multiple Canon bodies and several lenses. Since the camera body doesn't have true mechanical coupling to the lens aperture, why does metering differ between wide open and stopped down? Is this a known behavior with chipped adapters and stop-down metering on Canon DSLRs, and is there a practical workaround besides memorizing exposure compensation for each aperture?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

3

Canon cameras (as most DSLR cameras these days) meter and AF wide-open. There is a limit on the maximum aperture wherein metering and AF can perform properly, and a cutoff where they are unlikely to work at all. In modern Canon cameras, the metering sensor is up in the viewfinder housing, just above the eyepiece you look through. At narrower apertures (lets say smaller than f/8), the amount of light lost between the primary mirror, the focusing screen and the pentamirror/pentaprism is probably so much that the metering sensor has too little light to work with (well less than 50% of the light that originally entered the lens).

Metering sensors are usually rated in a range of exposure values. I think all of the cameras you listed are rated to work between 1 - 20EV and a certain temperature (roughly room temperature, although the exact value sometimes changes from camera to camera.) The 5D II might actually work from 0-20EV. Top-end professional grade cameras and newer mid-grade professional cameras can operate from -1 or even -2 EV up through 20 or more EV, and therefor have up to three stops more low-light metering capability than your average entry-level.

If you stop down your Contax lenses enough in poor enough scene lighting, you might be reducing the EV at the metering sensor below the minimum of its operating range. Since the metering sensor is designed to operate wide open, before an electronic aperture is stopped down for exposure, if you are working in weak light with a stopped-down manual aperture, you'll make it even harder for the metering sensor to operate correctly. You might simply try half-pressing the shutter with the aperture wide-open, meter, use the AE-Lock function to lock in exposure, stop down, and fully press the shutter button to take the photo at the previously metered settings.

Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user124

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes — this is a known issue with some adapted manual lenses on Canon DSLRs, especially with chipped adapters.

Canon DSLRs are designed to meter and autofocus with the lens wide open. If the adapter chip makes the camera think an electronically controlled EOS lens is attached, the camera may assume the lens is still wide open while calculating exposure, then compensate as if it will stop down at the moment of exposure. But your manual lens is already physically stopped down, so the camera can overexpose.

Stopped-down metering can also become less reliable at small apertures because much less light reaches the metering system through the DSLR optical path.

Practical workarounds from user experience:

  • Use Manual mode instead of Av mode.
  • Set exposure by watching the camera’s meter and adjusting shutter speed to center the indicator.
  • If using a chipped adapter, some users report better results by matching the camera aperture setting to the aperture set on the lens.
  • A non-chipped adapter may meter more predictably in stop-down use on some Canon bodies.

In short: the problem is real, body-dependent, and usually easiest to manage with stop-down metering in Manual mode.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer