Why do smooth sunrise gradients show banding in a RAW photo preview?

Asked 4/12/2015

4 views

2 answers

0

I shot a sunrise on a Canon 6D with a Canon 16-35mm f/4L at 16mm, ISO 100, f/22. In the sky near the sun I expected a smooth color gradient, but instead I see visible rings/banding. It becomes more obvious when I adjust exposure, levels, or saturation, and it appears in several of my darker bracketed exposures.

The file is an unedited RAW, and the day was unusually clear with no haze. Is this a sign that the image lacks enough tonal data, or could it be caused by the way the RAW is being previewed/processed in Photoshop?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

8

The first thing you must realize is that what you are seeing on your monitor is not the raw file. What you are seeing is an 8-bit demosaiced preview conversion of the raw file created by Photoshop (or whatever other raw conversion application you are using) based on the current settings. You may even be seeing the embedded jpeg preview in the raw file that was produced by the camera at the time you took the photo if that is what you have selected in the Photoshop preferences section!

What happens when you move sliders is partially determined by the choices you have made in Photoshop's preferences section. You can opt for faster but lower quality previews or for slower but higher quality previews. When you move some of the sliders the application reconverts the raw data based on the changes you made and displays the new 8-bit preview. With other adjustments the application will simply increase/decrease the value sent to the display. In both cases the application also keeps track of what settings you have selected and saves them without altering the actual pixel data in the file. When you export/convert the file based on the current settings the application will do the actual conversion and produce a new file in the output format you have selected: TIFF, PNG, JPEG, etc. Especially if you have Photoshop set up to convert the preview of an image on your screen more for speed than quality, what you see on the preview will not look the same as what you see when you actually convert the file.

Try actually converting the file to a high quality JPEG (same resolution as the original file and full color depth for the jpeg standard with minimal compression and see if the resulting file shows the banding that you are seeing in the on screen preview. If not, then look at your Photoshop preferences and change those "fast rendering" choices to "high quality".

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Most likely you’re seeing banding in the preview/rendering, not in the RAW data itself. A RAW file is not displayed directly; Photoshop (or the RAW converter) shows a demosaiced preview, often effectively 8-bit unless higher-quality settings/workflow are used. Smooth gradients like clear sunrise skies are exactly where preview banding becomes obvious, and pushing exposure, levels, or saturation can exaggerate it.

So this does not necessarily mean the sensor failed to capture enough data. It may be the conversion/preview settings, or even an embedded JPEG preview, rather than the underlying RAW file. Check your RAW converter/Photoshop preferences for preview quality and make sure you’re using the highest-quality processing path available.

Also, very clear skies with little haze can produce extremely smooth gradients, which makes any 8-bit preview banding easier to notice.

In short: the issue is probably not the lens or camera, and not necessarily a lack of RAW data—it’s usually how the RAW is being rendered for display and how edits are emphasizing those tonal steps.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer