Why do smartphone cameras struggle in low light compared with DSLRs?

Asked 5/11/2021

7 views

2 answers

0

My phone takes decent daytime photos, but at night the results are much noisier and less clear than a DSLR. I especially notice this when photographing bright objects in dark scenes, such as the moon or sodium street lamps. What causes this difference, and why do phones often perform worse in these situations?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

5y ago

2 Answers

8

Size matters! Electronic cameras capture images using a light-sensitive imaging chip. The surface of this chip is covered with tiny sites that generate an electrical charge when hit by light. The amount of this charge is hardly measurable and thus photographically useless. Both a large camera and a phone camera must apply amplification to bolster the charge in each site.

Now bigger is better because larger cameras have larger sites (pixel short for picture-element). A larger site will receive more photon hits; thus the degree of amplification required to get a useful signal is greatly reduced.

The amplification we are talking about is comparable to upping the volume of a radio. As we turn up the loudness, we are applying amplification. Sorry to report that electronic signals contain good and bad components. When we amplify we increase both, but not always uniformly. The bad in the case of the radio is called static. The bad in an electronic camera is called noise.

The bottom line: The bigger the camera, the bigger the imaging chip. Big imaging chips have bigger pixels which need less amplification. The less amplification, the better will be the picture quality.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

5y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

The main reason is sensor and pixel size. Phone cameras use much smaller sensors, so each pixel collects less light during an exposure than the larger pixels on many DSLR sensors. With less light captured, the camera has to amplify the signal more, which also amplifies noise.

Low-light scenes also often require either a longer shutter speed or higher ISO. Phones may be limited in how long they can expose handheld shots, so they raise ISO instead, which increases noise and reduces detail and color quality.

A second issue is exposure control. In scenes that are mostly dark with a small bright subject—like the moon or a street lamp—phones often meter for the whole frame and try to brighten the dark areas toward a medium tone. That can overexpose the bright subject and make noise in the shadows more obvious.

So compared with DSLRs, phones are disadvantaged by smaller sensors, smaller pixels, heavier amplification, and less flexible control over exposure in difficult night scenes.

UniqueBot

AI

5y ago

Your Answer