Why do my interior HDR merges look gray and muddy, and how can I improve them?
Asked 9/28/2020
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m new to HDR and tried merging 5 bracketed exposures of an interior room with bright windows for a real-estate style photo. My bracket was -3, -1.33, 0, +1.33, and +3 EV on a Sony A7R III with a 16-35mm f/2.8 GM. When I merge them in Photoshop HDR Pro, the result looks gray, flat, and muddy rather than vivid.
Is this caused by my shooting method, my exposure choices, or Photoshop’s HDR processing? Is there an automated way to get a decent result, or do I need to blend the window view separately with masks? If I reshoot, how should I set the base exposure for interiors with bright windows?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
1
Since it's a dark room while it's brightly lit outside, HRMerge is possibly wasting a lot of the dynamic range to make the outside fit. I would try to use only the shots where the outside is overexposed to create the HDR picture. The outside can then be added back using layer masks.
Originally by user75947. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75947
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Your result is likely a mix of shooting and processing issues.
For interiors with bright windows, the camera meter often bases exposure on the bright window light, so your “0 EV” frame can still be too dark for the room. A better approach is to set your base exposure for the interior—by metering away from the windows or using spot metering on an interior area—then include additional frames to hold detail outside the windows.
Also, Photoshop’s HDR merge isn’t always the best-looking option for this kind of scene. Several photographers prefer dedicated HDR software, which often gives a better starting point with less muddy output.
A practical workflow is:
- expose for the interior as your baseline
- bracket enough frames to cover the windows too
- if needed, build the HDR mainly from the interior exposures
- blend the properly exposed window view back in separately with masks
One answer also noted possible veiling flare from the windows, which can lower contrast and make the image look washed out. That can’t always be fixed well in software.
So yes: your bracketing idea is generally fine, but for a better result, expose for the room first, capture a separate window-safe exposure, and consider dedicated HDR software or manual window blending.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does my HDR interior photo look gray and muddy, and how can I improve it?
How can I avoid blurry tree branches when merging bracketed HDR shots?
How can I keep indoor office photos consistently exposed near bright windows with a Canon 100D?
Why HDR merges become 8-bit or 16-bit, and how 32-bit HDR fits into the workflow
How should I blend bracketed real-estate exposures manually in Photoshop?