Why do I see color banding in Lightroom Mobile and how can I reduce it?
Asked 12/19/2020
5 views
2 answers
0
Some of my photos show strange colored patterns/posterization in smooth dark areas. I notice it more in Lightroom Mobile/CC than in Lightroom Classic, and it briefly appears in the Develop module before the preview updates. The effect is less obvious on some cloud galleries, but still present in the file. What causes this, and what can I do to prevent or reduce it?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
3
I do agree with the "banding" result, but in my experience is it not caused by compression(*) but by heaving post processing:
- If you start with a JPEG image, the dark parts of your images are coded with very few bits, so there aren't very many possible color combinations, which isn't much of a problem because our eyes don't see much color in dark areas. If you do some color analysis on your picture, it contains 13K colors... but only 180 in the background, with only about 50 colors in any 200x200 area.
- When you lighten these parts, you don't add more color combinations but the color themselves, being less dark, are more identifiable as colors, and the 1-bit differences between dark colors have become much wider value jumps. So where the value jumps in contiguous pixels groups you see a hard limit.
Away to avoid this is to "dither" the colors before processing. If the 8-bit picture is loaded as a 16-bit (or more) image, pixel values can be fuzzed a bit to take advantage of the full range of values (a bit as if you added random decimals to integers). This suppresses areas where all pixels have the same values and so value jumps occur at more random places and become invisible.
(*) heavy compression can cause it but it also comes with other artifacts that aren't visible in the submitted picture.
Originally by user75947. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75947
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
What you’re seeing is color banding/posterization: visible steps in what should be a smooth tonal or color gradient.
Based on the answers, the usual cause is limited bit depth plus heavy editing, especially lifting dark areas. JPEGs are most prone to this because 8-bit compressed files contain fewer distinct tones, particularly in shadows. When those dark areas are brightened, the gaps between tones become visible as bands or strange color patches. Different apps/previews may show it more or less clearly, which is why Lightroom Mobile can make it look worse than other platforms.
To reduce it:
- Start from RAW if possible, and edit/export in 16-bit when available.
- If you must use JPEG, use the highest-quality version and avoid repeated recompression.
- Be gentler when pushing shadows or making heavy color changes.
- A small amount of added noise/dither can sometimes hide banding.
- Keep in mind your display may also be 8-bit, so some banding may be from the screen preview, not just the file.
If the image is already strongly banded, there usually isn’t a perfect fix; prevention is better than repair.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What’s the difference between Lightroom Classic, Lightroom CC, and Lightroom on my PC?
Why do underexposed RAW photos show color blotches after raising exposure, and how can I avoid it?
Can I disable cloud syncing in Lightroom CC entirely?
Why does Lightroom Classic’s Library module show extra grain or banding compared with Develop?
Can you hide “All Synced Photographs” in Lightroom Classic’s Catalog panel?