Why do harsh lighting conditions make shadows look darker?

Asked 5/3/2013

4 views

2 answers

0

If a shadow is simply an area where direct light is blocked, why do shadows appear darker in harsh light than in soft light? Shouldn’t the shadow itself be about the same brightness regardless of how strong the main light is?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

8

There are two factors here. One is the relative brightness the other is how directional the light is. Normally, light comes from multiple sources or is highly reflected. In this case, shadows are soft or non-existent because light hits where the shadow is from other directions than the one that is blocked.

Harsh light is generally very bright and very directional. The intensity of the light means that the dynamic range (the difference between the brightest and darkest part of the image) of the camera is going to require more light to be present in the shadow area to get a good exposure (since it can't overexpose the bright part). Compounding that, since the harsh light is very directional, it casts a harder shadow with less light being reflected or diffused to fill the shadow from other angles.

This is why you often see professional photographers using diffusers and reflective umbrellas with their flashes and using multiple flashes that are off camera in order to spread the light out and make sure light reaches the areas that would otherwise be dark shadows from a point light source (an intense light emitted from one point in space).

Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11392

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Shadows usually look darker in harsh light because of contrast, not because they contain no light.

A shadowed area rarely gets zero light. It often still receives reflected or scattered light from the surroundings. With soft light, illumination comes from many directions, so those shadow areas get more fill light and the transition is gentler.

Harsh light is typically both bright and directional. The lit areas become much brighter, while the shadow areas receive relatively little fill. That increases the difference between highlights and shadows, so the shadows appear darker by comparison.

In photography, this is also an exposure issue: to avoid overexposing the bright areas, you often expose for the highlights, which can make shadow regions record much darker. So the key idea is that “darker shadows” usually means greater tonal separation between bright and dark areas, not necessarily that the shadow has less absolute light than every shadow in softer lighting.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer