Can a reflector or off-camera flash soften harsh midday sunlight, or only fill shadows?

Asked 3/31/2014

6 views

2 answers

0

When shooting a person in harsh midday sun, does adding a reflector or external flash actually make the light softer, or does it only reduce the deep shadows? For example, in a 3/4 portrait, if the sun is strong and directional, is the overall look still harsh even if I add fill from one side? I’m trying to understand whether reflectors/flash can create soft-looking light outdoors, or if truly soft light mainly comes from golden hour, open shade, or studio lighting where the light source is larger and more controllable.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

4

Direct sunlight is a very hard light - that means the edges of the shadows are sharp and that the shadows are very dark - people tend to look bad in this light.

A big reflector near the model reflect soft light (because it's big and close) even if the light hitting it is hard sunlight.

So, if you position your model so that most of the are facing the camera are lit by direct sunlight with a reflector on the other side you have a hard key light with a soft fill.

But if you position the model so that most of the area facing the camera is in shadow and then add a reflector you suddenly have a soft key light - much better looking.

At the extreme you can position your model with his/her back to the sun (obviously this doesn't work mid-day when the sun is directly above) so what you get is basically a silhouette and then add a reflector in front to be the only light hitting the model - now you have a soft light portrait with the hard direct sunlight working as a heir light or a kicker.

You can always control the direction of light (relative to the model and camera) by moving the model and or camera, you can always change the light quality and color with a reflector or random objects you find in the shooting location - difficult ambient light just means you have to be more imaginative and work harder.

Originally by user2481. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2481

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Harsh midday sun is a hard light source: it creates dark shadows with sharp edges. A reflector or flash can reduce contrast by filling those shadows, but that does not automatically make the sun itself soft.

What matters is which light becomes the main light and how large it appears relative to the subject.

  • If direct sun is still the key light and you add a reflector/flash from the other side, you usually get hard key light with softer fill.
  • If you place the subject so the camera-facing side is in shade, then use a large reflector close to the subject as the main light, that reflected light can look soft because the reflector is large and nearby.
  • Backlighting the subject and using a reflector as key can also produce a softer portrait look, when the sun angle allows it.

So you’re not wrong: fill alone doesn’t necessarily make the overall lighting soft. To get a softer look outdoors, you generally need the key light to be larger or more diffused—such as a large reflector, open shade, or later-day sunlight.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer