Why do colors look different when I open a RAW file from Camera Raw into Photoshop CS6?

Asked 3/25/2014

1 views

2 answers

0

In Adobe Camera Raw in CS6, the image preview looks correct, but after I open the RAW file into Photoshop to continue editing, the colors shift and look different. Why does this happen?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

9

The image in the preview comes from an embedded JPEG inside the raw file which was generated by the camera, while the image you see when you open the raw file is generated based on the raw data.

The raw image data is captured from the camera at a point before the contrast and color settings are applied.

Every manufacturer's camera comes with embedded color profiles and contrast curves which dictate how colors and contrast will look when converting from the raw image data into a full color image, as is done when the camera generates its own JPEG image or the embedded JPEG inside a raw file. These color profiles have subtle differences between manufacturers, for example some of them emphasising skin tones or blue colors, and others taking a more "natural" approach vs wanting their own characteristic "look". Even the "normal" contrast setting can vary between camera manufacturers, each trying to get their images to look the best.

When using third-party raw editors to generate an image from the same raw data, that third-party raw editor probably doesn't use exactly the same color profile that your camera manufacturer does. It also won't necessarily honor the same contrast curve (or contrast setting) that you selected in-camera. Thus, the image will look different: brighter, darker, less or more contrasty, or individual colors emphasized or de-emphasized.

If you use raw editing software by the same manufacturer as your camera, you may be able to use the same color and contrast settings that are baked into your camera, ensuring a good result. However, just because something looks "the same as in camera" doesn't mean it looks better - ultimately, a raw editor will give you greater control over color and contrast than your camera's built-in settings will, resulting in greater scope to modify the final product.

Originally by user3422. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user3422

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

This usually happens because you are not seeing the same rendering at each stage. A RAW file contains sensor data plus an embedded JPEG preview made by the camera. That preview uses the camera maker’s own color profile, contrast curve, and processing, so it can look more like the in-camera JPEG.

When Photoshop/Adobe Camera Raw opens the RAW file, it creates a new image from the RAW sensor data using Adobe’s own RAW conversion and color interpretation. Since RAW data is captured before the camera’s JPEG color and contrast settings are applied, the Adobe-rendered version can look different in color, contrast, and saturation.

So the color change is generally normal: the preview is based on the camera-generated JPEG look, while the opened image is based on Adobe’s interpretation of the RAW data.

To minimize the difference, check your Camera Raw color/profile settings and use a consistent color-managed workflow in Photoshop.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer