Why do Canon extenders only fit certain lenses?
Asked 8/29/2010
2 views
2 answers
0
Why are Canon teleconverters/extenders only compatible with some Canon lenses? I’d like to use one on less expensive lenses too. Is the limitation mainly physical, optical, or autofocus related, and are third-party extenders any different?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
16y ago
2 Answers
6
The lens mounts have a specification over the maximum distances that elements can extend backwards - with EF-S lens, this is further back than on an EF lens. With an extender, which differs from extension tubes that don't contain any optical elemetns, the situation is reversed -- compatible lenses cannot go as far back as the normal EF lens specifications allow.
Adding an extender also has a big effect on the amount of light reaching the sensor and, more importantly, focusing systems, which can cause problems, and leads to unsupported configurations.
In either case, you may find you get away with it, but it may not be the same quality that you'd normally come to expect.
Originally by user21. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user21
16y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Canon extenders are limited by both physical design and performance concerns.
Physically, Canon teleconverters have a front optical element that protrudes forward of the mount. They only fit lenses whose rear elements do not extend too far back into the mount area. Many incompatible lenses, including EF-S designs, use that rear space, so the extender would interfere.
Optically and operationally, extenders also reduce the amount of light reaching the sensor and autofocus system. That can hurt AF reliability and overall image quality, especially on lenses not designed to work with a teleconverter. So even if a combination can be mounted, it may not perform to normal expectations.
Third-party extenders may use a different front-element design and can sometimes fit lenses Canon extenders will not. But fit does not guarantee good results; image quality and autofocus support may still be compromised.
So the restriction is not arbitrary: it’s mainly about rear-element clearance, plus maintaining usable optical and autofocus performance.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI16y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Are third-party teleconverters available for Canon lenses, and are they worth considering?
Why aren’t Nikon TC teleconverters compatible with DX and many zoom lenses?
Can you use a teleconverter with a Canon EF-S 55-250mm lens?
Can you increase working distance with a 100mm macro lens?
Which third-party speedlights work with Canon's RT radio system?