Why do cameras only offer certain shutter speeds and aperture settings?

Asked 12/5/2011

1 views

2 answers

0

On DSLRs and other cameras, shutter speed and aperture are usually offered in full, half, or one-third stop increments rather than as arbitrary values. For example, you might get 1/20s or 1/30s, but not 1/19s or 1/33s. If a camera can manage very fast speeds like 1/4000s, why aren't custom intermediate values available? And why are aperture choices also limited instead of being continuously adjustable? Is this mainly a technical limitation or a usability/design choice?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

14

Most DSLRs let you choose shutter speed and aperture at 1/3 of a stop difference (3 clicks of the dial to double or halve the amount of light), I'm not a camera designer but I would guess that since 1/3 of a stop is a small difference being able to set exact shutter speed isn't worth the extra electronics and software to support it.

For aperture also add to that the limitations of the camera-lens connection.

So, in other words:

  • 1/19 and 1/33 are nearly identical to 1/20 and 1/30 that are supported.

  • This feature will be slower to operate than just turning the wheel so pro won't use it

  • This feature will be complicated so amateurs won't use it

  • You can use the time it would take to develop this feature to work on features people are actually willing to pay for.

If you were a camera designer what would you have done?

Originally by user2481. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2481

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Mostly it’s a usability and design choice, not a hard technical limit.

Cameras organize exposure in stops so shutter speed, aperture, and ISO can be traded off easily: one stop faster shutter equals one stop wider aperture or one stop higher ISO. Using standard full/half/third-stop steps makes exposure quick to set and easy to understand.

Values like 1/19s and 1/33s are so close to 1/20s and 1/30s that they offer little practical benefit. Adding arbitrary values would make controls slower and more complex for very little real-world gain.

For shutter speed, modern cameras may internally time exposure very precisely anyway, especially in auto modes, but there’s usually no compelling reason to expose every possible value in the user interface.

For aperture, there can also be physical and communication limits between camera and lens, though historically some lenses did allow more continuous adjustment. Standardized marked f-stops became popular because they simplify exposure calculation and operation.

So the limitation is mostly about keeping camera operation fast, consistent, and useful rather than because 1/19s or similar settings are impossible.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer