Why can two webcams with different published field-of-view specs show similar or unexpected framing?

Asked 7/7/2013

1 views

2 answers

0

I compared two Logitech webcams placed side by side while aimed at graph paper. One is listed at 50° field of view and the other at 60°, but at the same distance the 50° camera appeared to show slightly more width than the 60° camera. I expected the larger FOV number to always show a wider scene. What does webcam field of view actually mean, and why might published FOV specs not match a simple side-by-side test?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

8

Field-of-view is the angular extent shown through the lens. For fixed-lens cameras, and all web-cams that I know of, the field-of-view is normally stated relative to sensor-size. This is very reasonable since the lens is fixed and cannot server on something else.

While this sounds like numbers could be compared, there several reasons why not:

  • Field-of-view can be measured vertically, horizontally and diagonally. Those numbers are not the same but some manufacturer only quote one of them and do not say which one. If you have to guess, it is usually the diagonal field-of-view.
  • Field-of-view changes with focus. As a lens focuses, there is often change in its field-of-view, particularly when close-focusing. Most field-of-view numbers are stated with the lens focused at infinity. Actually, even the focal-length changes when away from infinity! Unfortunately, there is no formula for what happens to field-of-view as focus is changed because it depends on the particular optical design of the lens.
  • Field-view varies with aspect-ratio. On cameras that shoot with different aspect-ratio, a reduced field-of-field is possibly shown. Only a few makers special field-of-view by aspect-ratio. A common example is switching between SD (4:3) and HD (16:9) video but the same thing applies with image-formats (3:2, 4:3, 1:1, etc).
  • Digital processing reduces aspect-ratio. Certain features reduce the displayed aspect-ratio to save some boundary pixels used in their computation. This is always the case for electronic stabilization and most often used for multi-shot techniques like Multi-Frame Noise-Reduction, and HDR plus geometric corrections such as distortion correction,

Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1620

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Field of view is the angular extent the camera sees, but published webcam specs are often not directly comparable.

A few things can explain your result:

  • FOV may be quoted as horizontal, vertical, or diagonal. Manufacturers often don’t say which one, and diagonal is common.
  • FOV depends on both lens and sensor size/shape, not just focal length.
  • FOV can change slightly with focus distance; specs are often given at infinity focus, while your test was close-up.

So a webcam listed as 60° is not guaranteed to show more width than one listed as 50° unless both numbers are measured the same way and under the same conditions.

In general, if two cameras use the same definition, the larger FOV angle should show a wider scene at the same distance. Your side-by-side test likely differs from the published spec because the two manufacturers’ numbers are based on different measurement directions or test conditions.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer