Do quoted camera field-of-view specs include lens distortion?
Asked 11/17/2022
6 views
2 answers
0
When a camera maker lists horizontal, vertical, or diagonal field of view, is that usually the ideal rectilinear/pinhole FOV for the focal length and sensor size, or can it include the lens’s real projection and distortion?
I’m asking because with CCTV and dashcam footage, strong barrel distortion often shows scene content outside what a simple pinhole-model calculation would predict. In one example, my camera calibration gives an undistorted FOV of about 85.4° horizontal, 54.9° vertical, and 93.3° diagonal, but the published specs say 116° horizontal, 61° vertical, and 139° diagonal. That only seems possible if the published numbers are based on the distorted image.
So: are manufacturer FOV specs sometimes measured from the actual recorded image rather than derived from focal length and sensor size? And if so, does that mean you generally can’t reliably compute focal length from those published FOV values alone?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
3y ago
2 Answers
1
They can do whatever they want... there is no standard/requirement that I know of.
The sensor that camera uses records a 16:9 aspect which is 1.78. The aspect they report as being recorded is 1.9; so it must include some barrel distortion **along the horizontal median line. The aspect you determined is 1.5 and would also include distortion; this time pincushion distortion.
** assuming no significant distortion recorded on the vertical aspect of a 16:9 rectilinear image.
Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user70370
3y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — published FOV specs can include the lens’s actual projection/distortion, especially on dashcams, CCTV, and other very wide-angle cameras. There isn’t a universal standard forcing manufacturers to quote only rectilinear/pinhole-model FOV.
For these products, makers often report the angle the camera can “see” in the recorded image, which may include barrel distortion or even fisheye-like projection. That explains why your measured undistorted FOV can be much smaller than the advertised horizontal/diagonal figures.
So your conclusion is reasonable: if the spec is based on the distorted image, you generally cannot back-calculate focal length from the published FOV and sensor size using the simple rectilinear formula. That formula only applies to a pinhole/rectilinear model.
In short:
- rectilinear/pinhole FOV and real recorded FOV are not always the same
- wide-angle camera specs often reflect the distorted image
- advertised FOV alone may not be enough to infer focal length accurately
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI3y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do I calculate the Nexus 5 camera’s field of view correctly?
Should crop factor be used when calculating camera field of view?
How do I calculate focal length for a 1 m × 1 m field of view at 10 m distance?
How do I calculate focal length in pixels from horizontal and vertical field of view?
How do you calculate angle of view from sensor size and focal length?