Why can two RAW photos with different ISO and shutter speed show slight hue differences?
Asked 1/1/2025
1 views
2 answers
0
I shot two sunset photos in manual mode on a Canon 7D Mark II with the same aperture, but with different shutter speed/ISO combinations: 1/100s at ISO 400 and 1/60s at ISO 800. After viewing the RAW files with a fixed white balance, one image looks slightly bluer while the other looks slightly greener. The RAW histograms also seem a bit different.
I expected shutter speed and ISO changes to affect only brightness (aside from noise), not hue. Can changing exposure and ISO cause small color shifts in RAW files, especially in low light, or is this more likely due to demosaicing / RAW processing?
Originally by Krzysiu. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Krzysiu
1y ago
2 Answers
8
The reason is because the camera sensor doesn't actually record colors. Instead it records the amount of light received per pixel after some wavelengths are (mostly) rejected (filtered out by the RGB color filter array (CFA)).
During the demosaicing process the color of each pixel is then calculated using the values of the photosite's recorded brightness as well as the values of photosites surrounding it. However, the different pixels/colors are not weighted equally. I.e. the green centric pixels are weighted more heavily in terms of exposure because human perception is also more sensitive to green centric wavelengths. There's also 2x as many green filtered photosites as there are red and blue.
For this reason, significant under/over exposures (exposure shifts) will result in different colors that cannot be recovered in post. I.e. photographing a color chart using the ETTR technique will result in colors that cannot be recovered to the same values as they would record at with a neutral (unshifted) exposure.
The specifics of the demosaicing algorithm vary (as do CFA's, etc); but I'll give a hypothetical example.
Let's say we have red exposed at a value of 1 green exposed at a value of 2 and blue exposed at a value of 3 (1/2/3); and RGB are weighted at factors of 1/3/2 for a 1/6/6 RGB result. Next we record (or exposure shift) the initial values brighter by a value of 2; so we have 3/4/5 weighted the same 1/3/2, for a 3/12/10 result. And no matter what we do with a linear/global adjustment, we will not be able to get the 3/12/10 result back to a 1/6/6 base result.
Originally by Steven Kersting. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Steven Kersting
1y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Small hue differences between two RAW conversions are usually due to processing, not because shutter speed or ISO directly change color.
A camera sensor records light intensity through red, green, and blue filters; it does not record full color per pixel. Color is reconstructed later during demosaicing, using neighboring pixels. Because Bayer sensors have twice as many green-filtered photosites, and because the channels are weighted differently, small exposure differences can lead to slightly different channel relationships after demosaicing or exposure compensation.
In general, RAW sensor data is very linear: changing exposure time or ISO should mainly change signal level/brightness, not hue. One community test developed your two RAW files with identical white balance and exposure compensation and found them to match very closely.
So the most likely explanation is that the visible shift comes from the RAW conversion workflow, including demosaicing and how the software handles exposure changes, rather than from the sensor itself. Low-light conditions can make these small differences more noticeable because noise and channel imbalance are more pronounced.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI1y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does an equivalent exposure table differ from the Sunny 16 rule?
Why does part of my photo have a bright/dark band on a Fujifilm X-T100?
Why does the moon look more orange at 1/400s than at 1/200s?
If ISO stays the same, how do aperture and shutter changes affect a photo with the same exposure?
Why can auto mode and my manual settings look the same even with different ISO and shutter speed?
