Why can a lens have lower contrast wide open?

Asked 5/4/2014

3 views

2 answers

0

Some lens reviews say a lens has reduced contrast at its widest aperture. Optically, what causes this? How can a lens lower contrast, and why does stopping down often improve it?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

14

There are two kinds of contrast the review might be talking about. Despite sharing a name, they're really two different concepts (isn't language awesome?). They both might be related to aperture, though, so without context, it's hard to guess which.

The first is micro contrast, which is explained in detail at What is "micro contrast" and how is it different from regular contrast?. In short, this is more closely related to the perception of sharpness than to the overall impression of tones, and lenses vary in this way due to the optical formula used and quality of materials.

A lens can also affect the overall contrast, by introducing veiling glare. You can read a bit about that as part of my answer to What characteristics make a good lens good?, and some related concepts at Is it possible for a lens to produce too much contrast? The basic concept here is that stray light bouncing around in the lens raises the lowest black level to a shade of gray, reducing the overall range of tones between that level and pure white. So, a lens with a lot of veiling glare will have reduced overall contrast.

Both of these can be affected by aperture — see the note about veiling glare at What impact on image resolution does the aperture have?, and some technical detail about micro contrast here: For MTF, why does 10 represent contrast while 30 represent resolution? (note that the different colors on an MTF chart typically represent different apertures).

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A review may mean two different things by “contrast.”

One is micro-contrast: the lens’s ability to separate very fine tonal differences in small details. This is closely tied to the perception of sharpness and depends on the lens design, optical formula, and material quality.

The other is overall image contrast, which can be reduced by veiling glare or flare inside the lens. Stray light scatters within the optics and adds a low-level wash over the image, making dark areas less dark and lowering contrast.

Aperture matters because when a lens is used wide open, light passes through more of the outer portions of the glass, where aberrations and internal scattering effects are often harder to control. Stopping down blocks some of those rays, so less stray or poorly focused light reaches the sensor, which can improve both apparent sharpness and overall contrast.

So the short answer is: lower contrast wide open is usually due to either reduced micro-contrast, increased veiling glare, or both.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer