Why are my photos soft with a 10-stop ND filter, even when focus seems unchanged?
Asked 5/19/2015
5 views
2 answers
0
I tested a Haida ND 3.0 (10-stop) filter on a Nikon D810 with a Tamron 24-70mm at 70mm. Without the filter, my shots at 1/6 sec are sharp at 100%. I autofocus first, then switch to manual focus, attach the filter holder carefully, and use a remote release with mirror-up/electronic front curtain. With the filter, exposures around 49 seconds look blurred, almost like camera shake. If I remove the filter and shoot again without changing focus, sharpness returns.
Settings were f/8 and ISO 100, and there was no wind. Is this likely a defective ND filter, or are there common causes of blur with long exposures and strong ND filters that I should check?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
1
When doing long exposures, you usually stop down to a small aperture to be able to lengthen the exposure. If you were at f/16 or f/22 you can get blur due to the diffraction limit of your lens.
If you look at twigs in the background, you can see they look almost double. Unless there is some sort of internal reflection due to the filter, it looks like camera shake. Sounds like you did everything right (remote release, mirror up etc). Are you sure your tripod was well set up and locked down? How long was the long exposure?
So to troubleshoot this, I would do another experiment but keep the lens at f/5.6 or f/8 to reduce softness due to diffraction. Also set up the tripod securely and try a range of shutter speeds from long (10+ seconds to eliminate anything that might be caused by releasing the shutter) to short (1/30 or 1/60 if you can, to reduce the opportunity for wind or tripod movement.
You can put a filthy UV filter with fingerprints all over it on a lens and not see much difference in image quality, I would doubt a filter would directly cause blurriness. But I know from experience that diffraction can cause a lot of softness, and in your case it really does look like camera movement.
Originally by user4191. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4191
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
This is more likely a long-exposure technique issue than a defective filter.
From the tests and comments, the blur looks more like camera shake or stabilization/focus-related problems than simple focus error. A few things to check:
- Turn vibration reduction/image stabilization OFF when the camera is on a tripod. VR/VC can introduce blur during long exposures.
- Keep the tripod fully locked down and repeat tests on a very stable surface.
- Focus before attaching the 10-stop filter, then avoid touching the setup. If switching to manual focus causes slight movement, you can leave AF enabled and use a release-priority setting so the shutter still fires even when the camera can’t focus through the dark filter.
- Stay around f/5.6 to f/8 for testing. Very small apertures can add diffraction softness, though at f/8 that should not be the main issue here.
- Try a range of shutter speeds to see whether blur increases with longer exposures.
Based on the follow-up testing, disabling VR and avoiding disturbance to the camera when changing focus/settings produced sharp results with the filter.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can I focus through a 10-stop ND filter using live view?
How should I meter a Bronica ETRS with a 10-stop ND filter on film?
Should I buy a 9-stop or 10-stop ND filter for long-exposure water shots?
How do I calculate exposure and shoot correctly with a 10-stop ND filter?
Why would a 10-stop ND filter have a less reflective outer surface than the lens-facing side?