How do I calculate exposure and shoot correctly with a 10-stop ND filter?
Asked 6/3/2012
8 views
2 answers
0
I’m using a Hitech Pro Stop 10 ND filter in a Lee holder and my first test shots came out much darker than expected. What’s the correct workflow for using a 10-stop neutral density filter? How should I meter the scene, calculate the new shutter speed, and are there any practical tips for long exposures with this kind of filter?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
7
The general approach I use with ND filtration is to compose and meter your scene first without filtration. I also use the Lee filter holder, which has the handy feature that allows you to clip/unglip the actual filter holder to/from the lens adapter fairly easily. The general process to expose for any amount of ND filtration, including the Big Stopper or other large-stop filter, would be as follows:
- Attach the Lee filter adapter ring to lens. Set camera to Manual mode.
- Fully meter the scene at a fixed ISO of 100:
- Evaluative metering will work well with average scenes of relatively balanced tonal range. (Make note of shutter speed.)
- Selective spot or partial metering will often be necessary with scenes of divided contrast or uneven tonal range. (Make note of shutter speed.)
- If you are also using Graduated ND to compensate for contrast, meter highlight, midtone, and shadow areas to determine total dynamic range
- Set aside the shutter speeds for graduated compensation in a later step.
- Compose scene in-camera without filtration.
- Adjust aperture here if necessary for artistic/stylistic effect.
- Apply ND filtration and compensate shutter speed:
- Multiply the shutter speed by the filtration factor:
- This is easy to calculate. Take 2 to the power of the number of stops of ND filtration:
- If applying a 2-stop/0.6 ND filter, multiply shutter speed by 22, or 4
- If applying a 10-stop/3.0 ND filter, multiply shutter speed by 210, or 1024
- Multiply the shutter speed by the filtration factor:
- Apply Graduated ND (GND) filtration (Optional):
- GND filtration should not be compensated for in-camera, as the intent is to mitigate highlights for a given exposure.
- The amount of GND filtration necessary in stops can be computed as follows:
- Divide the longer shutter by the shorter shutter.
- Take the log of the shutter speed quotient
- Divide the first log by log(2)
- Apply white balance correction (Optional):
- If you are using a considerable amount of ND filtration, strong color casts may appear
- These can be corrected in post, however they are often EXTREME, and may not be fully correctable
- To ensure viable correction in post, compensate in-camera first (according to manufacturer's recommendations and settings)
- Lee BigStopper tends to cast very, very blue...so set WB to around 10k or more
- HiTech 10x ND also tends to cast rather blue, so a setting near or even above 10k might still be needed
- Other brands may cast very magenta or violet-blue, some cast very green or yellowish
If you have a smartphone with a calculator, computing these is extremely easy in the field. You can also try to memorize a few things to help you quickly arrive at rough settings without the need to use a calculator. Here is a table of ND stops filtered to shutter speed multipliers (Ratios provided for Lee/Singh-Ray filter users...just add up all the fractions of your ND filter stack):
ND Stops | ND Ratio | Multiplier
==================================
x1 | 0.3 | 2
x2 | 0.6 | 4
x3 | 0.9 | 8
x4 | 1.2 | 16
x5 | 1.5 | 32
x6 | 1.8 | 64
x7 | 2.1 | 128
x8 | 2.4 | 256
x9 | 2.7 | 512
x10 | 3.0 | 1024
----------------------------------
Example Scenario #1: Simple ND filtering
You wish to photograph a serene river scene, completely blurring out not only the motion of water, but also the slight rustling of the leaves of the trees, creating a very dreamy style of photograph:
- The scene has roughly even tone, no GND filtration is needed
- You use evaluative metering, and compensate down by 1/3rd of a stop
- Aperture f/8
- ISO 100
- Shutter meters at 2 seconds
- You want to apply 6-stops of ND filtration (1.8 ratio)
- Shutter speed needs to be increased by a factor of 64: 128 seconds, or about 2 minutes
Example Scenario #2: Complex ND+GND layered filtering
You wish to photograph a cloudy coastline just after sunset, blurring the soft waves to a fog and flattening clouds. You need to compensate for the sun, which is just below the horizon and brightly illuminating the sky relative to the sea.
- The scene has high contrast, so GND filtration is necessary
- You spot-meter the sky near the sun, and get an exposure of 1/50th second
- You spot-meter the sea near the horizon, and get an exposure of 1/3rd second
- You spot-meter the rocky coastline, and get an exposure of 1 seconds
- Total difference in stops between the sea and sky: @4 stops
- log(1/3rd / 1/50th) / log(2) =
- log(.3333 / .02) / log(2) =
- log(16.6667) / log(2)
- Total difference in stops between the sea and coast: @1 2/3 stops
- log(1s / 1/3rd) / log(2) =
- log(1 / .3333) / log(2) =
- log(3) / log(2)
- (Check) Total difference in stops between sky and coast: @5 2/3 stops
- log(1s / 1/50th) / log(2) =
- log(1 / .02) / log(2) =
- log(50) / log(2)
- Three levels of GND filtration necessary:
- One 2-stop soft grad filter for the division between coast and sea
- One 3-stop and one 1-stop hard grad filter for the division between sea and sky
- Alternatively, drop the extra 1-stop hard grad if you are worried the sky may end up too dark with an additional 10-stop filter, or you intend to slightly under-expose to preserve highlights
- You use center-weighted or partial metering on the sea:
- Aperture f/8
- ISO 100
- Shutter meters at 1/4th
- You want to apply a 10-stop BigStopper (3.0 ratio) or similar ND filter
- Shutter speed needs to be increased by a factor of 1024:
- 1/4s x 1024 / 60s/m =
- 0.25s x 1024 / 60s/m =
- 256s / 60 s/m =
- 256 second or 4m 16s exposure time
- Shutter speed needs to be increased by a factor of 1024:
Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user124
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A 10-stop ND filter is used like any other ND filter: meter and compose first without the filter, then add the filter and adjust exposure.
Basic workflow:
- Mount the adapter ring/holder and compose the shot.
- Set ISO and aperture first.
- Meter the scene without the filter and note the shutter speed.
- Add the 10-stop filter.
- Multiply the metered shutter time by 1024 (roughly 1000) to get the new exposure time, while keeping ISO and aperture the same.
Example: if the unfiltered exposure is 1/30 sec, the filtered exposure will be about 34 seconds.
Because exposures often become very long, you may need Bulb mode for anything beyond your camera’s normal shutter-speed limit. A timer, watch, phone, or ND calculator app can help.
If the result is too dark, you need more exposure time, or you can open the aperture or raise ISO if appropriate. It’s also normal to experiment—try 15s, 30s, 60s, etc., and refine from there.
One more tip: very small apertures like f/22 can make sensor dust much more visible in long-exposure images, so if you see spots, check for sensor dust.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
When stacking a CPL and ND filter, which should go closest to the lens?
Cokin vs Lee filter systems for landscape work on a wide-angle lens
Why am I getting reflections or light leaks with a Lee Super Stopper 15-stop filter?
How should I meter a Bronica ETRS with a 10-stop ND filter on film?
If you can buy only one ND filter, which strength is the most versatile?