Why are gray cards used for white balance instead of pure white cards?
Asked 1/20/2012
1 views
2 answers
0
I understand that an 18% gray card provides a neutral target for setting custom white balance. But why is gray commonly used instead of a pure white target?
Is it because gray is easier to manufacture consistently, less likely to stain or yellow, or because white can cause exposure/clipping issues when the camera measures the reference?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
15
When you have already set your exposure parameters, white could be clipped in some single color channel (but not all, so your camera won't show it as blown), therefore not being very good basis for color balance adjustment.
Also, paper will turn yellow during time. And just looking at the sheets currently on my desk, there's three different tones of white papers already.
That said, I've used white paper many times and it will get you close enough in all but very critical studio shoots. Very often you'll have multiple different light sources, reflections from colored surfaces and/or shadows vs. lit areas, all having much more impact on colors than slight imperfection in metering the white balance. Just make sure you don't clip any color channels (e.g. by spot metering without compensation from the paper, or verifying exposure parameters using color channel histograms).
Originally by user4390. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4390
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For white balance, the important property is neutrality, not whether the target is gray or white. A neutral white, gray, or even black target can work if it reflects all colors evenly.
Gray cards are commonly used because they’re also useful for exposure, and an 18% gray target is less likely to overexpose. A bright white target can clip one or more color channels, especially if you use fixed exposure settings, which makes it unreliable for white-balance measurement. Gray gives more headroom and more consistent results.
Another practical issue is that many “white” materials aren’t truly neutral: paper can vary in tint and may yellow over time. A proper gray card is made to be spectrally neutral and consistent.
So the reason isn’t that gray is inherently better for white balance than white; it’s mainly that a neutral gray card is a safer, more repeatable reference and avoids clipping while also doubling as an exposure tool. In casual use, a non-clipped neutral white target can still work well enough.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why is setting a custom white balance on Canon DSLRs more cumbersome than on video cameras?
Auto white balance vs custom white balance: why are the results different?
Why does white balance use neutral gray or white as the reference?
How can I white-balance using white, gray, and black reference cards mathematically?
Are 18% gray cards mainly for exposure, and can they also be used for white balance?