Why are flash ratings given in watt-seconds instead of joules?
Asked 2/22/2019
97 views
2 answers
0
Studio flashes are often specified in watt-seconds (Ws) rather than joules (J), even though 1 Ws = 1 J. Is there a practical reason the photography industry uses watt-seconds for flash energy ratings instead of simply using joules?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
5
Well, it's convention. And the convention makes sense since J is an energy unit associated with work and heat in general while Ws is in terms of power (specifically electrical power) and time which are units relevant to the photographer.
If I can shoot with 1kW of lighting at 1/10 sec, I can equivalently use a flash with 100Ws of energy (assuming similar efficiency of course, so this is just a first estimate).
This convention is very common with electrical energy, not just in photography: you will pay for electrical energy billed in units of kWh rather than units of MJ.
Originally by user82185. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user82185
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Mostly, it’s convention. Watt-seconds and joules are the same unit of energy: 1 Ws = 1 J.
In flash photography, manufacturers traditionally use watt-seconds because it relates more directly to electrical power over time, which is how flash energy is stored and discharged. A flash capacitor stores electrical energy and releases it in a burst, so “watt-seconds” feels more connected to the device’s electrical behavior than “joules,” even though they are identical mathematically.
It also matches other common electrical-energy conventions, such as kilowatt-hours on utility bills rather than megajoules.
One important point: a flash’s Ws rating refers to electrical energy in the unit, not the actual light output. Different flashes can convert that stored energy into light with different efficiencies, so the same Ws rating does not always mean the same brightness.
So the short answer is: there’s no special technical reason that prevents using joules; the industry uses watt-seconds because it’s the established, electrically intuitive convention.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can you compare a speedlight’s guide number to a studio flash’s watt-seconds?
What flash power do I need for small still-life photography at around f/5.6?
Why do some modern speedlights list longer full-power flash durations than older flashes?
Can a Canon A-1 use a modern speedlite or radio flash trigger?
Can Lightroom 6 use all CPU cores when building standard previews?